posted 06-09-2002 01:28 AM ET (US)
chad,The thing to do is drill the stripped screw holes out with a 1/4" bit and glue in a 1/4" plug of teak. Chisel the plug(s) flush and reinstall the hinges.
This is the best way and it's also the easiest. If the damaged hole(s) are larger than 1/4" then go to a 3/8" hole. Cut your own plugs from a scrap of teak and a hardware store plug cutter or buy preformed plugs at West Marine or some other chandlery.
For glue I would use 5 minute epoxy because I have it around and it provides nearly instant gratification as well as having really good gap filling properties if the damaged holes are a little odd in their shape. Polyurethane glues like Gorilla Glue or ProBond will also work well.
I would try to align the grain of the plug(s) with the grain of the hatch but the hinges will mostly cover the plugs so it's not super important to be perfect in this regard.
If you are going to refinish the hatch while you’re doing this repair, you can just sand the plugs and glue down when you sand the hatch to bare wood. Otherwise a sharp chisel is best to flush the plug out without loosing the finish or weathered look of the teak.
Another alternative you could use in lieu of, or in addition to, plugging the holes, would be to use machine screws with nuts on the underside. You might have to mortise them into the underside of the hatch if the fasteners fall where the lip in the hull is. If the stripped holes are already too large then you will have to plug them and redrill for the machine screws.
Marine Tex is a bad idea as it is not like wood in its physical properties and it will not look good if a bit shows around the hardware. Longer screws probably will go through the hatch and even if they don't they will only be gripping with the amount of extra length they provide, like 1/4”. That’s not enough.