Moderated Discussion Areas
ContinuousWave: Whaler Performance
the power of 25 or conveniece of 15?
|Author||Topic: the power of 25 or conveniece of 15?|
posted 08-09-2002 08:50 PM ET (US)
I have a 1969 whaler that used to have a 1983 25 hp Evinrude on it. The motor definately packed all the power we needed. However its ruined and we arent quite sure what to go with now. The place that we keep the boat is on saltwater and running water and electricity are impossible so we cant flush it or work on it. It is also in an area where a new motor could be stolen. So we're considering down sizing so that we can carry the motor off and bring it home to flush and keep safe, therefore a 15 would be more convenient. Also we are definately going to go with a foreign brand such as yamaha or tohatsu. I know that tohatsu makes an 18 but we'd rather get a yamaha 15 or 25. Is 15 hp enough to plane a 13 footer with two people and four tanks?, Is there a foreign brand that makes a 20? and where's a good place in florida to get a fairly new freshwater used yamaha?
posted 08-09-2002 09:16 PM ET (US)
"billster9000" IMHO - If security is a big problem, I'd go with the motor that you can remove, none of your other criteria means anything if you go out one morning and your motor is gone. You can lock your motor. I got a lock at West Marine and it fit my 15hp Evenrude but wouldn't fit my new 25hp Honda.
posted 08-09-2002 10:15 PM ET (US)
I don't think that puting a 15hp on 13'er
is the best idea. I have a 15hp on my boat. and i love it. but..... I go out by myself. and my whaler is only 11 feet. If a have a lot of people in my boat it will plane but the people must my siting in the right places. For the part when you want to move the outboard.........well a 15hp is about 90 pounds. u can carry it but it is not fun. and i dont know how u will get it on the boat if u keep u keep your boat in the water. remder that a 13 foot whaler is rated for a 40hp.
posted 08-10-2002 02:02 PM ET (US)
This is a tough decision. The performance of a 13 with a 15 is going to be marginal, even without much weight. I had a 25 Evinrude on a 13 and it ran 30 on the GPS. However, getting ripped off is terrible, especially since they might just cut the transom off in order to get the motor. I'd go with the 25, chain the boat up, lock the motor, and then insure it (if you can get coverage).
Remember, you can't stop someone from stealing what they want, if they try hard enough they'll get it. They could steal the motor when the boat's locked in the garage. You've just got to make it too difficult to bother.
posted 08-11-2002 09:09 PM ET (US)
There's a few things I should have added. The boat is on a floating dock and we keep the car about 60 feet away so as long as the motor isn't as heavy as the one we had on there it should be alright. Also, the old motor broke due to problems relating to the saltwater and the inability to flush it. That is our main Concern. As long as far as security, we've never had any problems it's just that we dont have and cant afford insurance on it and other people with nicer boats have had break ins. My only question now is if the 18 tohatsu would plane with a good speed and if tohatsu is a good company to go with.
posted 08-11-2002 09:47 PM ET (US)
I have a 15 hp Nissan, same as Tohatsu, that I use on my 13'. It runs well and planes well. I have never checked the speed, but even with wife and two small children, it zips right along. There is a dealer that I stop by from time to time in an area of Georgia that has quite a few rivers, and he says that those guys like the Tohatsu becasue they are faster than the comparable hp from other manufacturers. He wasn't trying to sell me one, just talking about motors in general. Kelly
posted 08-11-2002 10:36 PM ET (US)
I recently replaced an 18hp nissan with a four stroke 15 hp yamaha. The nissan was much more powerful and was reliable for 10 years without any service other than changing the oil in the gearcase and replaceing the water pump. I would definately look into the nissan. Its a great motor.
posted 08-12-2002 09:23 AM ET (US)
Was that dealer in Valdosta?
Curious, Jim Armstrong
posted 08-12-2002 09:37 AM ET (US)
No, Dublin Marine, in Dublin, GA. I have talked with them a couple of times. Seem like nice people. They carry Mercury, Yamaha, Tohatsu, Carolina Skiff, and some aluminum boats.
posted 08-12-2002 01:13 PM ET (US)
My opinion is get the 25, get a used one and lock it up. Getting 20 years from an engine is damn good, and I doubt flushing would have extended it's life much longer. Anything over a 6hp is a bitch to carry and if you think having one stolen stinks, wait till you drop one off the back of the boat.
posted 08-13-2002 09:27 AM ET (US)
|soggy bottom boy||
posted 08-14-2002 12:55 PM ET (US)
I agree with BigShot. Nothing more heart breaking than watching your outboard 'jump' off your transom and plunge to the bottom! Happened with an Evinrude 18 and a rental boat. Know have a 20 Johnson. Sounds like progess, but that 18 ran perfect.
Purchase our Licensed Version- which adds many more features!
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 2000.