If the area to repair is on the top of the center console and will be highly visible, the surface layer of the repair should be done with a color-match gel coat resin.
If the unused mounting holes will be covered by new equipment and will not be in view, you can just use epoxy with thickener to fill them. The WEST System Epoxy repair kit is a good source of everything you will need to fill many old fastener holes.
In either case, you can use a thickened and tinted epoxy resin to initially fill the holes, but because epoxy resin will tend to yellow with exposure to sunlight, you should not use epoxy resin for the surface layer if the holes will be in prominent view.
The 0.5-inch diameter hole may need some high-density filler for the resin and some fiberglass cloth material on the back side.
When using gel coat resin for a repair, the resin should have a wax additive and be in the form of a paste consistency. The wax is need because usually a polyester resin will not cure to a hard surface if it is exposed to air. Alternatively regular polyester resin (without wax) can be covered with a layer of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) to keep out the air.
For details on the process of using epoxy and gel coat resin together, see
The Epoxy Curehttps://continuouswave.com/maintenance-logs/epoxy/You can purchase small quantities of repair gel coat resin paste material (at crazily high prices) from Spectrum. Read about an alternative source at
Alternative Source for Color-Matched Gel Coat Resin with Waxhttps://continuouswave.com/forum/viewto ... f=6#p50373Or you can use normal polyester gel coat resin and tint it yourself to match the color, then spray PVA to enable a hard cure.
Your success at tinting white resin to match DESERT TAN or OUTRAGE GRAY gel coat will depend on the acuity of your color vision.
The original gel coat finish on the console should be washed to remove all dirt, any oxidation in the surface resin removed, and the surface buffed to a gloss finish; in this way you will be able to see the true color of the original surface.
A simpler and much faster approach to filling unused old fastener holes is simply to put a new stainless steel screw into them. Unless there are multiple holes and in highly visible locations, a random machine screw head appearing in a console surface is not a particularly unusual visual element.