For the 16-foot hulls prior to 1972 the year of production can only be determined in an approximate basis from the stencil number. In the REFERENCE section of the website--and by the way the website is not just this forum, it is a much larger collection of information--in the REFERENCE ARTICLE on the 16/17-foot hull you will find a table that lists the approximate year of production for certain ranges of stencil numbers.
Inspecting the table for a stencil number of 3A5374 suggests the boat was made in 1972, as the table cites 3A6700 as the highest stencil number that year. A boat made in 1972 could easily be a 1973 model year, if the boat were made after about June 30, 1972, a typical model-changeover epoch.
While the Stencil Number is a hull identification number, we do not refer to the Stencil Number as a "HIN". The term "HIN" is reserved for the federal hull identification number that became mandatory in c.1972.
To learn more about the stencil number and HIN and what information is encoded in them, read the Frequently Asked Questions article in the REFERENCE section. Your question about the age of the boat is actually the oldest FAQ question.
Here are some hyperlinks:
The REFERENCE SECTION:
https://continuouswave.com/whaler/reference/The FAQ:
https://continuouswave.com/whaler/reference/FAQ/The REFERENCE ARTICLE on 16/17-foot Hulls:
https://continuouswave.com/whaler/reference/Regarding the model designator, the COHASSET II model will have a reversible pilot seat (RPS) instead of individual pedestal seats.
Q2: what is the color of the gel coat resin in the cockpit of your boat?
Also, typically only Boston Whaler boats that were made after November 1972 would have a federal hull identification number (HIN) attached. The initial method of providing a HIN was to use an embossed metal tag and attach the tag at each end with a pop rivet into the hull on the outboard face of the transom about two-inches below the gunwale on the starboard side.
In the case of a c.1972 boat today, the metal tag would need to have endured 50-years of boating. For the metal tag to have become lost is nothing unusual. The only remnant of the tag may be two small rivet holes about four or five inches apart on the transom where the tag was once located.
If new to the website, please read the entire FAQ. It will answer many basic questions about Boston Whaler boats. There are also extensive archives of prior discussions going back about 20 years. These can be searched by keyword from a site search page at
https://continuouswave.com/whaler/search.htmlA search with well chosen keywords will usually find interesting information on the topic.
ASIDE: Articles in the forum are not charged by the word, so there is no need to compose as if sending a telegram to Pitcairn Island and trying to keep the cost down.