posted 07-17-2001 10:17 AM ET (US)
Bryan,The 17' Montauk and the 17' Outrage are not at all the same. The Montauk is closer in hull design to your 15 where as the 17 OR is closer to the 18 OR in design.
Montauk: 16' 7", 100 hp max
17 Outrage: 17' 6", 120 hp max
18 Outrage: 18'6", 150 hp max
It's a really big (and nice) step up from a Montauk to an 18 OR. The 18 OR is basically half again as much boat; half again as much horsepower, half again as much weight and capacity. Plus it is a V-hull instead of a tri-hull. Because of this gap, Whaler introduced the 17 OR to round out their product line.
The 17 OR is very close in design to the 18 OR in that it has the V-hull and built in fuel tank. I believe it was the last Dougherty designed Whaler as well. I have never ridden in a 17 OR so I don't have any firsthand experience with its performance but I have owned both the Montauk and the 18 OR so I may be more than a little biased If I suggest that these are the boats to look at.
It really comes down to price and room for storage. If you can afford it and store it, then go for it. On the other hand, the Montauk is such a classic (dare I say one of the best boats ever conceived) that I kinda' think you ought to own one just for the experience.