posted 09-24-2001 10:34 PM ET (US)
Ron3637,
Wow, plenty of votes for the Montauk, and well deserved too.Blackdog to bad you missed the Wye River Regatta. I have a small tale to tell……
Most of the Chesapeake Whaler Club launched out of Kent Narrows that morning. There was a good stiff wind and a heck of a chop.
There was a (I guess 80's vintage) 22 Outrage, 18 Outrage, two Montauks and me in my Dauntless 16 (the smallest of the fleet).
It was a very rough ride (airborne quite a bit) across the Eastern Bay to the mouth of the Miles River. The 22 and the 18 Outrage handled this stuff with ease. The 22 did better though. I ended up drafting the 22's wake for a better ride. One Montauk we met up with slowed down and caught up with us later. They were more like me, did not care for the bucking bronco ride on the water that day. One of my comments at Wye Landing was that it was times like that which makes you want a bigger boat, while I eyed the 22 Outrage.
Well after the regatta we all headed back. One of the Montauks screamed back crest to crest at around 43 mph WOT. I cut back 600 rpm because I did not want to get beat up as bad again, and another Montauk that was following me cut back even more.
When I got to the No Wake zone I saw the first Montauk and was worried about the following Montauk. I was starting to go back to look for him when he came in. So I headed in.
When I talked to the fellow members after they came in I was surprised to find out that the first Montauk in had almost all the heads of the screws holding his bow rail had sheared off. The second Montauk that came in after me had slowed down after he had lost the screws on a stanchion on his bow rail and was in damage control mode. These Montauks were powered with 90s and were 7 - 8 mph faster than me at WOT. This is where a 115 HP outboard like Blackdog's would have been nice. All the Whalers made it through that mess at a good speed, and this was a time were length really mattered in comfort. What surprised me was I had received a nice comment from one of the Montauks on that my Dauntless appeared to take the chop better. There were some other nice comments about my boat from some of those on the Montauks. I believe these guys love their boats and would not trade them for the world, but it was nice to hear. From my point of view all of us in the smaller hulls got thrown around pretty good that day.
Moral, don't count out the Dauntless. I have taken mine out on the Bay in some rough stuff, something I do not plan to do again, and it can handle it. I am getting older and like a smoother ride through a chop. I live off the Corsica, talk about skinny water at times, and the 11 inch draft works well for this.
If you want go fast get a 115 like Blackdog, he does around 45 mph with two people, the same as a Montauk with a 90. I might have gone with a Suzuki 115 4-S if it had been around when I bought my boat. The Dauntless 16 also has a 45 gal in deck tank.
Heck just give it chance. It might not be your cup of tea. The Montauk has a larger cooler seat and I believe a larger cockpit. The Montauk is a great boat, and someday the Dauntless just might be considered one also.
The Odd Man Out,
Bear