|
ContinuousWave Whaler Moderated Discussion Areas ContinuousWave: The Whaler GAM or General Area New Boston Whalers without Mercury outboards.
|
Author | Topic: New Boston Whalers without Mercury outboards. |
WT |
posted 02-11-2009 05:45 PM ET (US)
An email from my Boston Whaler dealer, The Outboard Motor Shop, Oakland, California. The Outboard Motor Shop is now able to get select new Boston Whalers without a Mercury outboard. For the next 90 days, we have worked a deal to buy select Boston Whalers with a blank transom. We have struggled to get loans for customer these days for any boats powered with anything but an Evinrude or Honda motor. Evinrude E-tec and Honda have certain agreements with banks to continue lending on boat packages. If you are interested in a new Boston Whaler with a motor choice, please give craig a call and we can discuss motor options. I can be reached at (510) 533-9290 or emailed at craig@outboardmotorshop.com You can also visit our web page at www.outboardmotorshop.com |
L H G |
posted 02-11-2009 07:51 PM ET (US)
[Changed the TOPIC to speculate about how other outboard motors will perform when installed on certain Boston Whaler boats. I consider speculation about performance to be a topic more suitable for the PERFORMANCE discussion, and I invite everyone to initiate discussions about speculations of performance in the PERFORMANCE discussion. Rather than change the course of this discussion into a new discussion about LHG's speculations of performance, let's remain on the topic of the news being announced--jimh.] |
jimh |
posted 02-11-2009 08:39 PM ET (US)
Warren--Thanks for this news. I had heard rumors about this possibly happening, but, even with a few months of foreshadowing, I am still surprised that it has happened. In a difficult economy, it seems entirely reasonable that a boat builder might loosen any restrictions which tend to limit the sale of their boats. |
elaelap |
posted 02-11-2009 08:52 PM ET (US)
WOW! Finally. See, it's true what they say: every cloud has a silver lining. Now please tell us which "select" models can be purchased this way, Warren...I know you've been eyeballing that MT 190 for a while. Tony It's going to be very, very interesting to compare the prices of Whalers without Mercury motors with the same models with their usual motors, just to find out how BW/Brunswick/Mercury values their outboards. Very interesting indeed...Watch Larry and a couple of others here do some amazing intellectual gymnastics when these data become available ;-) |
elaelap |
posted 02-11-2009 08:57 PM ET (US)
Ya know, carefully parsing Craig's (the dealer's) email, it sure isn't absolutely clear that they'll sell a customer a hull without any motor at all. Maybe you get a motor choice, with Hondas or E-TECS, which is a good thing, but somehow I doubt you can just buy a motorless BW. Hope I'm wrong! |
Ritzyrags |
posted 02-11-2009 09:33 PM ET (US)
Well, Hourra, for free enterprise here; And it is at all possible that I may have predicted this new development in prior comments. Better to sell a beautiful Whaler as an actual reality then not selling it at all on a technicality; such as power. We all have our preferences such as in Outboard Power and I will suggest that the proof is in the Pudding. In my short experience with outboards,I have owned a certain number of units such as Mercs,Johnsons, Evenrudes, Yamahas, Mariners, Hondas and other loaners..and all to be appreciated to a degree of preferences. The fact is with a generic cowling having all the same shapes and no markings I will suggest that most of the better quality ones will pretty well perform in very similar manners.Except for the outboard sounds... The big thing for me Gentlemen will be residing in the realms of RELIABILITY/PERFORMANCE and very importantly fuel efficiencies. I have no preconceptions about power but will instinctively lean toward our traditional North American brands. Having said that I will aver that I dearly love my Four stroke Honda 15 HP kicker as this unit has proven without a doubt to have performed splendidly for all the years that I have employed it. What is really wrong with owning a Rocket Power House like my V6 Offshore 150 Mercury Gentlemen? And this being a repower from the original Dealership that brought the Outrage from the Whaler plant? I will suggest to you that there is absolutely nothing left to be desired and better as far as raw power,good service and just lately fuel economy; At cruise,the Verado 150HP delivers up to to 26% more MI/GAL than Suzuki 150HP and up to 43% more MI/GAL than Evinrude 150HP-ETEC. Not to turn this tidbit into a plug here but my point being; What is really wrong about getting a brand new Merc on a brand new Whaler, Gentlemen? I will risk in saying "Absolutely nothing!" Show me the Money.. |
SC Joe |
posted 02-11-2009 10:32 PM ET (US)
I wonder which "select" models these might be? What are the lowest sellers? |
Yiddil |
posted 02-11-2009 10:51 PM ET (US)
I won't speculate on what models nor would I speculate as to why, or even speculate as to how much more or less it will cost. All I would say is that giving buyers opportunities to pick and choose different motor manufacturers is a plus for every buyer who has longed for more choices in spending their hard earned cash on Boston WHalers. I think its a fantastic opportunity for buyers all around. It will be interesting to see how this goes for them, if they get the performance specs they need to determine the best possibilities for the boats they do sell. Wish they had that going when I was buying mine:) |
HAPPYJIM |
posted 02-11-2009 11:01 PM ET (US)
It will be interesting to see if all those guys that complained about not being able to buy a new Whaler without an option of their motor will step up to the plate and buy one now. |
L H G |
posted 02-11-2009 11:16 PM ET (US)
What if someone wants to buy a Whaler with no engine, like I did with all of mine, and take it to a Mercury dealer of their choice offering better pricing for an Optimax engine, or a self rig through the internet. Can one do that? Hope so. A 170 with an Optimax 90 would be a nice rig. Too bad the factory won't do it. |
Peter |
posted 02-12-2009 09:27 AM ET (US)
Why shouldn't we be able to buy a boat without a motor? What if I want to use it as a flower planter in my front yard? Why do I need a motor for that? ;) Assuming that you were able to buy the boat as a bare transom, while towing it home for the purpose of using as a flower planter you could pass by your favorite Evinrude dealer whereupon you might get second thoughts about the flower planter idea and bolt on a nice 115 or 130 E-TEC, thereby gaining 25 or 40 HP while losing 30 lbs on the transom over the Mercury 90 FourStroke offering. Now that would be one HOT setup. ;) |
Tohsgib |
posted 02-12-2009 11:20 AM ET (US)
Man my 115 Suzuki would look good on a new 170...darn, it's 6lbs over the max transom weight. Gonna have to stick to my classic. |
L H G |
posted 02-12-2009 03:17 PM ET (US)
The problem with that idea, Peter, is that with the 115/130 E-tecs the boat wouldn't be any faster than with the Merc 90! |
andygere |
posted 02-12-2009 03:38 PM ET (US)
I doubt that the Outboard Motor Shop would sell you a hull with no motor whatsoever. The purpose of this special arrangement (from the shop's perspective) is to sell a boat and motor to a customer that wants to finance the package. Since it seems that the financing (or access to it) in this case is provided by Evinrude and Honda, it seems unlikely that the deal would be available for anything other than a boat and motor package that included either a Honda or Evinrude motor, and was financed via one of those firms. In any case, this is good for consumers since they have a choice of motors. Those who prefer Mercury could still have the Whaler of their choice with a Merc on the back, while Evinrude and Honda fans will be able to purchase some boats from the Whaler line with their favorite motor. The dealer is able to sell a boat/motor package to a customer that might otherwise go elsewhere. In the end, everybody wins. I am curious why Honda and Evinrude seem to be able to line up credit for these packages where evidently Mercury/Brunswick can not. In terms of available models, this will probably be determined by a number of factors, including what size/price motors are tied to the financing deals, and which Whaler models can be easily rigged with another brand of outboard (or said another way, which ones do not have a lot of Mercury rigging as an integral part of their manufacturing). |
pglein |
posted 02-12-2009 03:57 PM ET (US)
I inquired with my local Whaler dealership and received this rsponse today: "Peter; I have double checked with my Boston Whaler factory rep and as of two days ago they implemented a plan that for the first time you can order either the Montauk or Dauntless without a motor, so looks like you have the jump on this information as this is news to all of us here at the dealership. My factory rep is forwarding me all the information and said this is going to be a word of mouth only program as nothing will be published about it either online or in print. Please feel free to contact me if you have any additional questions and thanks for your questions. " Given Whaler's desire to keep it "word of mouth only", and my desire to support their decision to make this offering, I will not reveal here who I spoke to. But I think we can interpret this as further confirmation of the rumor. |
pglein |
posted 02-12-2009 04:01 PM ET (US)
Looks like it's time for some of you who said you'd order a new Whaler as soon as they let you do so without a Mercury engine to either put up or shut up! Put your money where your mouth is and support this company we all love for finally doing what we've been begging them to do for years. |
L H G |
posted 02-12-2009 04:52 PM ET (US)
Andy, to answer your question about why Honda and BRP have money to loan. You must be kidding about Honda. That company is a money machine, with a huge automobile backbone. The Japanese are loaded, with a huge trade surplus and money flowing in like crazy. They have billions to loan to US consumers and to the US treasury. Who do you think is going to partly finance the $800,000,000,000 Stimulus bill and $700,000,000,000 TARP?. They are rich from the world's purchases of their products, and we are poor and in debt, unfortunately. The sheer size of those numbers tells us how much bad debt this country's citizens have borrowed and recklessly spent, and now not able to pay back to the people who never should have loaned it to them in the first place. (and that includes boats, too) BRP is a Canadian company, and much to Canada's credit, they did not allow their banks get in into the trouble our Banks have with Sub-Prime mortgages and other reckless loans to people who had no ability to own a home or to pay back the Mortgages. As a result, BRP's banking connections in Quebec have plenty of money to loan to QUALIFIED buyer's of Canadian products, which includes Evinrude. |
elaelap |
posted 02-12-2009 05:44 PM ET (US)
[Shifted the topic of discussion to the issue of who is to blame for default in high-risk mortgage and other loans. This is outside the purview of our discussion.--jimh.] |
Feejer |
posted 02-12-2009 06:02 PM ET (US)
A white 150hp E-Tec sure would look great hanging off a Dauntless 180 |
Casco Bay Outrage |
posted 02-12-2009 06:37 PM ET (US)
quote: I was at a dealer this week and mentioned the Outrage 370. Only one sales guy heard of it but knew nothing about it. I gave them the IP address for the video and they watched it while I was there.
quote: These two statements are testaments to Whaler's PR department piss-poor ability to communicating product development and sales and marketing initiatives to their own dealer network. Sheesh! |
fourdfish |
posted 02-12-2009 08:15 PM ET (US)
If Boston Whaler is going to make any money on this they need to get the word out. If not, why do it at all? |
BlueMax |
posted 02-12-2009 09:55 PM ET (US)
There ya go Feej! |
SC Joe |
posted 02-12-2009 10:29 PM ET (US)
I agree with Fourd; it seems keeping this "word of mouth" only is counter productive. If their intent is to sell more Whalers, why would they not want everyone to know about it? My question is also about cost. How much do they knock off, say a new Montauk 170, after removing the engine, controls, tach voltage and water pressure gauges? Do these guage holes now have to be cut? Or are they just "plugged"? And does this amount make it worthwhile? I mean lets say a given Montauk is 30K with motor. With out the engine, they'll sell it for say, $27k. It's almost not worth doing, is it? |
fourdfish |
posted 02-12-2009 11:05 PM ET (US)
The only way Boston Whaler(Brunswick) can make any real money on this without hurting the Mercury Division is to price it with a surcharge equal to the loss of the money lost on the nonsale of the Mercury engine. Just economics! |
Peter |
posted 02-13-2009 07:23 AM ET (US)
As crazy as this sounds Larry, I agree with you.....in the circumstances where the Montauk 170 with the E-TEC 115/130 hanging on the transom is being towed behind the truck. That's the only time an E-TEC 115/130 wouldn't be any faster. ;) |
SC Joe |
posted 02-13-2009 09:19 AM ET (US)
If I had been given an option for an E-TEC over my Merc 4 stroke, I might have done it. I wouldn't have paid more for it either way though. I'm not convinced one motor is that much better than the other. |
L H G |
posted 02-13-2009 09:49 AM ET (US)
This special deal for the Outboard Motor Shop sounds like Boston Whaler is trying to help them stay in business. Will they be one of the thousands of Marine Dealerships expected to go out of business this year? |
hauptjm |
posted 02-13-2009 10:31 AM ET (US)
I can understand Whaler's choice to keep it word-of-mouth, to offset cannibalizing the parent company and Mercury. We can chalk this up to being informed and fortunate to be part of such an enlightened resource as ContinuousWave. |
Hilinercc |
posted 02-13-2009 11:08 AM ET (US)
Sounds like things are coming full circle here - choose your hull, choose your motor!. Remember when that was the norm, before the eighties?. It'll probabaly just be temporary until the economy picks up. If they can get Whalers out the door easier without motors, it will keep the plant going. |
andygere |
posted 02-13-2009 11:09 AM ET (US)
I doubt that the Outboard Motor Shop is in danger of going out of business. They've been around for more than 50 years, carry all the major outboard brands, provide good service and do a great deal of commercial business in addition to consumer retail. In terms of Honda, are they a money machine because they are a Japanese company, or is it because they are a well run company? How about BRP? The last time I checked, Canada was not immune to the same financial crises that is plaguing the U.S. Perhaps it's more about the company than the country. If Brunswick (including Mercury) products are so superior, why is that company not a money machine like Honda? Regarding the word of mouth deal, I suggest this is the case: Dealers are not trotting this news out there so folks like us who might pay cash for a new Whaler if we could buy it with our favorite brand of outboard. This deal is set up for the folks who have already closed the deal on a new Whaler, but can't get financing. The dealer then says, "Well John, if you'd be willing to take the new Montauk with this superior E-TEC on the back, we can get you a loan and put you in a new boat today." |
pglein |
posted 02-13-2009 01:32 PM ET (US)
I'd be willing to bet they are doing it to move boats they already have on hand or in production, or just to keep their workers doing something productive. I'm not privy to their internal financials, but I'd be willing to bet they make the majority of their profit on the engines, and may even operate the boat building operations at a loss. By selling boats without engines, they may be able to minimze this loss, by keeping their fixed overhead productive. |
fourdfish |
posted 02-13-2009 07:57 PM ET (US)
"thousands of marine dealerships expected to go out of business this year" OK, I know the economy is getting worse but WHO predicted that amount of dealerships will tank? |
RM NY |
posted 02-13-2009 08:05 PM ET (US)
I had heard this info months ago from a merc employee, was not sure if it would actually come to pass though. im sure if it meant selling a boat they would sell it painted pink with bunny ears sticking out the stern, times are rough for everyone. |
WT |
posted 02-13-2009 10:14 PM ET (US)
I wonder if they would sell me a 170 Montauk with a 115 Mercury on the transom? :-) Warren |
Whalerdog |
posted 02-14-2009 07:26 PM ET (US)
Funny if we treated Japanese Companies like Japan treats American companies Honda and the rest of them would be sucking wind. |
17 bodega |
posted 02-15-2009 01:08 AM ET (US)
It's about time. Someone finally realized that if they wish to stay "afloat", they will sell a boat any [expletive] way the customer wants it. Now why did that take so long? |
florida1098 |
posted 02-15-2009 10:55 AM ET (US)
good news |
SJUAE |
posted 02-18-2009 03:52 PM ET (US)
About time you guys had the same options as the rest of the world, never been a problem on export models :) http://img75.imageshack.us/img75/1049/dsc01922my4.jpg Actually I have never been so frustrated in trying to buy US boating products. You probably have the best selection of goodies at the best prices but trying to find someone to ship them is near impossible and the few that will only know how to via FED-EX/DHL etc which is totally cost prohibitive. What’s wrong with air fright. Even US postal service is riddled with exceptions and freight forwarding is hard work to private addresses. It's now cheaper to buy from UK that sells in pounds what costs in dollars in US, just because they are more flexible. Amazon won’t even ship to UK let alone UAE so I can’t even get them hand carried out by friends/visitors to here. A 110lb Yamaha 9.9hp costs 300USD air freighted yet a 40 USD engine tie bar weighing 6lb costs 80USD delivered and 13lb of engine gauges + binnacle cost over 200USD to be delivered etc ............ No wonder why companies are struggling these days, been spoilt by home market IMO (Sorry in advance Jim, minor off topic ranting) Regards |
pglein |
posted 02-19-2009 11:54 AM ET (US)
Steve, It's simple really. Although the UAE has a rapidly growing economy, there is still limited demand for certain products. In order to make shipment of items over such a great distance economical, it has to be done in bulk. And while there is clearly a rediculous amount of money flowing in the UAE, much of it still does not reach the working poor. Without a middle class, demand for items that are out of the reach of the poor like outboard motors or 15-30' fishing boats is still relatively low. Thus, it is not economical to set up a distribution channel for these products and ship them container loads at a time. So, you are left with only the option of buying and shipping one unit at a time. This method of shipping is very expensive on a per-unit basis. UAE is a nation in transition. I believe that in the coming years you will see an increasing number of these kinds of items become available at reasonable costs, but in the mean time, you just have to grin and bear it. Out of curiousity, do you see much in the way of a middle class developing in Dubai, or is it still mostly a two-class system? |
chopbuster |
posted 02-19-2009 04:34 PM ET (US)
I have it on very reliable authority that; The current BW policy regarding the optional installation This policy has been enacted as a result of emissions This policy is not, for the foreseeable future, inclusive |
Whaler19 |
posted 02-19-2009 04:45 PM ET (US)
I recently looked into buying a 170 Alert/Guardian with white interior/exterior totally bare with no console or rails. I wanted to install a taller BW console (maybe 18 dauntless console) and a Yamaha 4-stroke, not currently an option on the 170 Montauk. The price was $17,000 just for the bare white 170 Guardian hull. |
Mumbo Jumbo |
posted 02-19-2009 08:45 PM ET (US)
Well, Whaler can decide whether it wants to sell boats or not. I'm {b}not[/b] buying if the Whaler has a Mercury on it. Not buying, period. End of story. I know several dealers who have bemoaning the fact that their customers will not buy a "black thing" on the back of a Whaler. It has cost the dealers many sales. |
Mumbo Jumbo |
posted 02-19-2009 08:46 PM ET (US)
Well, Whaler can decide whether it wants to sell boats or not. I'm not buying if the Whaler has a Mercury on it. Not buying, period. End of story. I know several dealers who have bemoaning the fact that their customers will not buy a "black thing" on the back of a Whaler. It has cost the dealers many sales. |
Mumbo Jumbo |
posted 02-19-2009 08:48 PM ET (US)
I have apparently lost my mind. The sentence should say: "......have beenbemoaning....." |
Mumbo Jumbo |
posted 02-19-2009 08:49 PM ET (US)
I give up.
|
SC Joe |
posted 02-19-2009 09:19 PM ET (US)
>>>Well, Whaler can decide whether it wants to sell boats or not. I'm not buying if the Whaler has a Mercury on it. Not buying, period. End of story. I know several dealers who have bemoaning the fact that their customers will not buy a "black thing" on the back of a Whaler. It has cost the dealers many sales.<<< Will you buy a new whaler if you don't have to have Merc on it? |
SC Joe |
posted 02-19-2009 09:25 PM ET (US)
>>>I have it on very reliable authority that; The current BW policy regarding the optional installation of non-mercury engines on BW boats is, for the present, restricted to BW sales in the state of kalifornia only. This policy has been enacted as a result of emissions This policy is not, for the foreseeable future, inclusive Have they recently changed the emission requirements in Ca? Accodring to this, [ur]http://www.mercurymarine.com/serviceandwarranty/outboardfaqs/carb.php[/url] the Montauk 170 engine, (the 90 HP FOURSTROKE) is 3 Star CARB certified for 2008, and available for sale in California. |
Ritzyrags |
posted 02-19-2009 09:29 PM ET (US)
I wonder if it would be helpful to suggest a proposition that would offer to the public the same Mercury products; But instead of the one color option in BLACK To also offer the outboards in Ivory or Cream color.. So if this is really about a color thing.. It would be an easy and progressive fix. Is it the performance aspect? The sound of the engine..? Just wondering... |
Ritzyrags |
posted 02-19-2009 10:54 PM ET (US)
http://www.mercurymarine.com/serviceandwarranty/outboardfaqs/carb.php |
SJUAE |
posted 02-20-2009 12:07 AM ET (US)
pglein Thanks, your correct a few 100K western expats and 900K locals out of 6 million is not enough to have the same buying choices you have in the US. My findings seem to show that US chandlery merchants have been spoilt by the home market and are less flexible when it comes to international sales. Fed-ex-ing stuff around the US is cheap but to anywhere else it's ridiculous. You would think given the current financial climate anyone would be glad of a sale and happy to find a cheaper solution to forward goods other than by well know couriers, is my gripe. The middle class structure is very strange and transient in nature. If anything Dubai has overrated and over priced itself out IMO. Quite a few would like to see the new 25/35 ETEC's in white and I would have bought anyone’s 9.9 in white. I can’t see why BW can’t give its home market an option for a blank hull even if it has a slight premium attached, they already charge enough for all the other options, why not this. |
Peter |
posted 02-20-2009 10:23 AM ET (US)
"Have they recently changed the emission requirements in Ca?" No. But perhaps there is some credibility to the California only policy with respect to some products. In some of Whaler's offerings you can't get a 3-Star compliant Mercury outboard of a certain HP. Neither the Optimax 150 or the Verado 150 have a 3-Star rating. Thus, if you wish to power a 190 Outrage or a 180 Dauntless with 150 HP, you can't get a 150 HP outboard with a 3-Star CARB rating from Mercury. So Whaler's Mercury Only policy prevents consumers from obtaining high compliance with California's CARB regulations at the 150 HP level. |
Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Freeware Version 2000
Purchase our Licensed Version- which adds many more features!
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 2000.