posted 09-03-2013 08:11 AM ET (US)
I see two problems with using an Engel cooler:--the cost, and
--the battery drain.
Using Engel's MR040 model as an example--they say it is a very popular model--the price is $850. That will buy a lot of block ice, even at $4-per-block. Since we make our own block ice, the cost of ice for us is even lower.
The cooling mechanism is said to draw 2.5-Amperes at 12-VDC. That is a not a significant load if your outboard engine is running and providing charging current, which would be typical for a boat out fishing all day. When cruising, we might only run the engine for a hour or two per day. I don't know how much charge the outboard engine could push back into the battery during an hour or two. Could it keep up with the cooler discharge? I don't know. The compressor does not run continuously.
Also, the ambient temperature where the cooler is being used is a big factor. We just got back from cruising in northern Lake Superior. Among several boats, one cooler had ice still frozen after nine days.