Forum: WHALER
  ContinuousWave
  Whaler
  Moderated Discussion Areas
  ContinuousWave: Whaler Repairs/Mods
  Gel coat versus Awlgrip outside of hull

Post New Topic  Post Reply
search | FAQ | profile | register | author help

Author Topic:   Gel coat versus Awlgrip outside of hull
shoctor posted 11-21-2002 01:00 PM ET (US)   Profile for shoctor   Send Email to shoctor  
So in the previous attempts to sell the old girl I am at the same time figuriong out how to refinish this winter. I have heard conflicting reports about gel coating. The first being that in order for gel coats to cure they must be covered much like they are in a mold and not let air get to them ie painting gel coat on and covering with saran wrap. Other option I have heard of is to awlgrip the hull interior and exterior can anyone shed some light on this. I have read previous posts and seems like there has been a 50-50 split on gel coat and awl grip.
Shane
David Jenkins posted 11-21-2002 01:49 PM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
If you are willing to spend extra time and money on the job because you want it to be as good-looking and as durable and as long-lasting as possible, spray it with gelcoat. Getting it to cure correctly will not be a problem--follow the manufacturer's directions. Best of luck with it!
shoctor posted 11-21-2002 04:08 PM ET (US)     Profile for shoctor  Send Email to shoctor     
Can you shed any light on the cure methods I am a bit leary about attempting myself and turning the hull into a sticky mess. Also considered epoxying the exterior of the hull to fix inperfections then either the awlgrip or gel coat. I too am leaning towards gel coat but have been possibly scared off by the complexity of it. Also any suggestions for Brands?
tully_mars posted 11-21-2002 05:20 PM ET (US)     Profile for tully_mars  Send Email to tully_mars     
Just an FYI, Hatteras paints all their new yachts with Imron over the gel-coat because it holds its shine longer and better. If it is durable enough for those boats....

Tully Mars

DJS posted 11-21-2002 05:43 PM ET (US)     Profile for DJS  Send Email to DJS     
shoctor,

I used Spectrumcolor's www.spectrumcolor.com gel coat and did not have any trouble with it curing. In Spectrm's information sheet on using their gel coat they state the following: "Gel Coat will not fully cure without adding a surfacing agent (1/2 and ounce per pint) or overspraying with PVA before gel coat reaches its gel stage (approximately 5-10 min)."

I used the surfacing agent they supplied which is made by Fiberlay. The name of the agent is Surface Seal.

Hope this helps.

David

shoctor posted 11-21-2002 05:50 PM ET (US)     Profile for shoctor  Send Email to shoctor     
How difficult was the process overall and how did the results come out? Also did you spray or roll on? Am really considering giving this a shot. But any info would help.
Shane
Also what were the temps when you did this. Was thinking about this winter but in Northeast never warm enough I would assume need like 70 deg F and what were drying times. Did you apply one or more coats of Gel coat etc etc.
Thanks
Shane
shoctor posted 11-21-2002 05:50 PM ET (US)     Profile for shoctor  Send Email to shoctor     
How difficult was the process overall and how did the results come out? Also did you spray or roll on? Am really considering giving this a shot. But any info would help.
Also what were the temps when you did this. Was thinking about this winter but in Northeast never warm enough I would assume need like 70 deg F and what were drying times. Did you apply one or more coats of Gel coat etc etc.
Thanks
Shane
Cpt Quint posted 11-21-2002 06:28 PM ET (US)     Profile for Cpt Quint  Send Email to Cpt Quint     
My two cents...gelcoat is not a bit more expensive but much more expensive (x5+)

What are you redoing and what is the purpose for the boat? You need to ask yourself that to see how much $ you want to put into it.

If its a complete restore a $ no issue than have it gelcoated by proffesional. If its a fishing boat that you drag to shore than paint it.

David Jenkins posted 11-21-2002 09:59 PM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
In about a week I will spray my Whaler with gelcoat (multiple coats) so if you have not made up your mind by then, send me an email and I will share my experience with you.
jimh posted 11-22-2002 12:15 AM ET (US)     Profile for jimh  Send Email to jimh     
I don't think there are any "conflicting reports" about whether or not gel coat will cure to a hard finish when exposed to air: it won't.

As others mention above, you must provide some air seal, either with wax additives, PVA, or mechanical covering.

Where there does seem to be disagreement is on the problem of applying multi-part paints like AWLGRIP by a non-professional.

shoctor posted 11-22-2002 09:27 AM ET (US)     Profile for shoctor  Send Email to shoctor     
Well to say this caused a bit more of a dilema is an understatement LOL. I am pretty handy when it comes to stuff like this but am curious about the adding wax to the gel coat to make it harden not really sure how this works. Do you spray the wax over the applied gel coat etc etc or add it to the mix then spray. Boat is an Old Currituck that have had up for sale and no takers. All were expecting brand new boat i think when they came to look. Anyways If someone can shed some light on this topic it would be great. Also to fix some of the imperfections in the hull I was thinking of west systeming the hull with a filler to get a smooth finish is this a good idea? Then Gel Coating? Also approx how much resin and then Gel coat would I need to do a 16-17 footer?
Shane
David Jenkins posted 11-22-2002 10:10 AM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
Add the wax to the last batch you will spray. Proably will need 2 gallons. Detailed intructions come with the gelcoat if you order it from Spectrum or Mini-Craft.

Mini-Craft of Florida, 800-282-8244.

The problem will not be the wax, it will be the expense and the time needed to prepare the hull, apply the gelcoat, then sand and compound the gelcoat until it shines.

Contender25 posted 11-22-2002 10:18 AM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
I have re-gelcoated 3 boats and will be doing a 4th this spring. I will share with you what has worked for me.

Depending one where you purchase your Gel-Coat, it is NOT more expensive than Awl-Grip or Imron. The last boat I did, A Mako 19, a Gel Coat jobwas 1/8 the price of an Awl-Grip job (doing it myself)

Granted we used plain white gel-coat.

The prep work was easy.

1. Sand to original gel-coat (if previously painted), fill cracks dings etc with a polyester based filler or resin.(some say you can use Epoxy, just get rid of the ameine(SP??) blush.

2. Sand entire hull with 80 grit sand paper. Make sure you keep the sander flat against hull.

3. Wash hull with Acetone Tape boat. Trailer etc

4. Figure your working time with the gel-coat. Mix enough Acetone into the gel-coat so it will pass through your sprayer. I add the following way in a 2 quart mixing pail:

1: Add Gel-Coat
2: Add reqd' amt of MEKP
3: Thin with Acetone
4: Mix Thoroughly

Mix a small batch and time how long it takes to kick. REMEMBER this time. Temps Humidity, etc change things.


5. Mix a batch and begin spraying/rolling. Stop 1 min before the kick time and run to a waiting batch of ACETONE. Empty sprayer and douse everything with acetone, run acetone through sprayer assuring nothing will cure in sprayer.(VERY IMPORTANT)

6. While cleaning have someone mix another batch and begin spraying / rolling again.

7. Do this process until the boat is cover to 22mils of Gel. Took 3 coats on a Mako 19 using 1 gallon of gel coat.

Now the hard part:

The boat will now look terrible depending on your spraying skills, all orange peel, some runs etc. I am not a skilled sprayer so your skills may be better. Do not fret if it looks bad. The beautifying stage with gel-coat comes last. (for me at least)

1. For white/light color boats: rum Dye-Kem over the entire hull. Dye-Kem is a blue dye used when cutting sheet metals.

2. Begin sanding, making sure you keep the sander flat against the hull. Begin with a grit you feel comfortable with, do not cut too much. Some start with 120 other 100 and some 80 grit.

3. Stop and move to next section when the blue dye disappears. The blue dye shows the peaks and valleys so when it is all white you know to stop.

4. Switch grits up to desired finish, some 1000 others 1500 2000 etc.

5. Compound entire hull and wax.

Thinking about it,Gel coat is more expensive for a professional job as it is labor intensive. Material wise I have found it to be much less expensive.

1. Gal of Gel-coat w/ MEKP plus wax additive $50.00 From LBI Fiberglass

2. Acetone LOTS OF IT!!! $30-50

I am sure there are other ways of doing this process. This is the way that works for me. I have yet to roll gel-coat but plan on doing rolling the next boat.

Good Luck

I was unable to spell check sorry for any issues.


David Jenkins posted 11-22-2002 10:34 AM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
Contender25, how do you know when you are 22 mils thick?
Contender25 posted 11-22-2002 10:51 AM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
Good Question-

I have a "thing" (sorry I do not know what it is called) that you push into the gel coat. This "thing" has different measurements on it. When you push it into the gel-coat you can see the measurements in mils. Similar function as a spark plug gap tool, but much different looking tool.


Very hard to explain this tool, sorry. It cost about $0.35 at a fiberglass store.

In the test stage, I spray a coat on a board and measure the thickness of the coat. I can then determaine approx# of coats to reach 22mils.

I am unable to test the hull of the boat as the gel-coat hardens between coats.

It is also important to remember to "hot" coat (apply next coat when the previous is tacky) the gel-coat between coats.

For me, 3 coats is the ussually the magic #.

I will search the web to see if I can find a pic of the tool.


Contender25 posted 11-22-2002 10:56 AM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
Here is a link to the page:

Scroll down and it is the last item. Looks like I was WAY off on the price, sorry. it is $3.56. They through one in for free when I purchased my supplies last time.

http://www.lbifiberglass.com/lbiproducts/tools.html#anchor611318

David Jenkins posted 11-22-2002 12:53 PM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
Contender25, this is fantastic. Very helpful. I did not realize that time was such an important faactor when spraying gel coat. When the humidity is less than 50% and the temperature is about 60 degrees F, and you are using an activator that is designed to work at that temp, what is the approximate time before it "kicks?" And what exactly do you mean when you say "kick?" Does it kick and then get tacky? How long will it stay tacky? Thanks again for your help.
shoctor posted 11-22-2002 01:42 PM ET (US)     Profile for shoctor  Send Email to shoctor     
I was wondering the same. That site you listed was wonderful. I may actually think twice about selling the old girl now lol. If you could explain "kick" I would appreciate as well. I am also assuming the same methods could be used for the interior of the hull as the exterior..... Looks like I will have arms like Mr. Clean by the time I am done with all the buffing and waxing and sanding
Contender25 posted 11-22-2002 01:45 PM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
More good questions!

Time is most important for your spray gun. If the Gel-Coat Kicks (hardens) in the gun, it is game over for the gun.

Kick time is specific to each gel-coat and every temp/ humidity condition. This is why I stress a test batch to figure the excact time.

I have never done gel-coating below, maybe, 68 F at the lowest.

To the best of my recollection, when spraying the last job, the Mako 19, I had 7 minutes and 30 seconds of working time. It was a low humidity day and the temp was roughly 70-75 F.

At 7 min 30 secs I stopped, emptied out the remainder of the gun in a pail and ran the acetone through the gun.

I would fill the spray gun roughly 3/4 full of the Gel-coat, MEKP, and Acetone mixture. This amount would do 1/4 of the boat. (I had someone mix this concoction seperatly for me as I was cleaning the gun)

Spraying 1/4 of the boat at a time I worked my way around the boat three times.

That was it.

I let it sit overnight and began sanding the next day. I am pretty sure I could have sanded that day but I let it sit.

One other note on this job: after it was done I had to thouroughly wash the boat with Acetone before sanding to remove the excess wax that came to the surface. This was the only time I had to do this, rather odd, just keep this in mind in case you begin to sand the boat and your sandpaper is getting clogged frequently wash it with Acetone. It took care of the issue very easily. Unfortunatly, I had to re-apply the dye-kem because I put the dye-kem on and then realized the wax issue so I washed with acetone which took the dye-kem off.

One other note is the more people helping you the better. I did this project with 3 people. All I did was take care of the spray gun, a friend did the mixing, and a third to help out when needed.

As for "kicking" I have found that with the gel-coat, I use, it goes on wet, then after time becones tacky, but not for long, and then kicks rock hard.

"Kicking", to cure, is when it starts to cure.

Contender25 posted 11-22-2002 02:06 PM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
One thing I may mention is:

I have never gel-coated the inside of a boat. Not saying I wouldn't, I actually am plainning on undertaking it to two boats this spring, but I have yet to undertake that project.

Curves and corners makes fairing much more difficult. Flat sides of a boat hull are much easier.

shoctor posted 11-22-2002 02:08 PM ET (US)     Profile for shoctor  Send Email to shoctor     
One more question that I am a bit hazy on. Do you want to overlap the spray before it kiscks meaning if you can only cover 1/4 of the boat at a time do you move onto a new section and then return to the part sprayed or do you do all three coats then move on or lastly spray the whole boat with one coat then start over?
Thanks again
David Jenkins posted 11-22-2002 02:10 PM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
Contender25, I have misunderstood something. What I hear you saying is that you spray it on (wet), then it becomes tacky, then it becomes hard. When it becomes hard it is said to "kick." Last time you sprayed it, it kicked in about 8 minutes. Before that time it was tacky, after that time it was hard. Right? But perviously you said that re-coating the gel coat had to be done when it was "hot," or tacky. Right? Seems like if it took you 8 minutes to do 1/4 of the boat, by the time you got around to where you started, at least 30 minutes had gone by. Right? Was it still tacky? Had it kicked but was still tacky? If so, then I am missing something. Thanks for explaining it to me,
Contender25 posted 11-22-2002 02:41 PM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
Perhaps I mis-typed and confused things including myself, my apologies-

I did state it starts to kick within 8 minutes and does not stay tacky for long. Technially, This is wrong, I am sorry for the confusion. The gel-coat begins to kick in 8 mins and is pretty hard by 10 but chemically stays tacky and can be hot coated for 1-2 hours.

When a gel-coat is tacky it is different than paint. If you have worked with polyester resins, gel coat is the same. When tacky it is very dense and if touched it is a little "sticky" but would not rub off on your finger.

After 8-10 minutes it will probably have Kicked/cured enough to destroy a spray gun. After 10mins to 2 hrs you can still re-apply over a previously applied coating.

After 2 hours? No problem, just wash the area to be gel-coated with Styrene to liquify the wax on the surface of the previously applied coating and off to the gel-coating races you go!

Shoctor-

What ever works for you, I get close to the previously applied area but if you overlap you will have an area with perhaps 7x the thickness as the rest of the boat. Come close but try to keep things even.

David Jenkins posted 11-22-2002 02:55 PM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
Thanks!
shoctor posted 11-22-2002 02:58 PM ET (US)     Profile for shoctor  Send Email to shoctor     
Beautiful, I feel like racing home and starting now! I know seems easier than it really is but the end result seems to be better than that of painting the hull which I wanted to avoid. I was looking to refinish to Whaler spec. Now if replacing the old rude with a nice new 4s would be that easy and cheap I think I would be all set.
Contender25 posted 11-22-2002 03:25 PM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
At one time my thinking was re-painting with Awlgrip / Imron etc, was the only way to go when re-painting a hull. A very good friend of mine gel-coated his 20 ft sailboat and I was a convert after seeing the completed job.

There is no way I would try to gelcoat a boat over 30 ft but for smaller boat I like the gel-coat. I think a gel-coat job has a factory new finish.


David Jenkins posted 11-23-2002 09:49 AM ET (US)     Profile for David Jenkins  Send Email to David Jenkins     
In jimh's excellent article on repairs in the reference section he mentions wearing a respirator, protective clothing, gloves and a shower cap when sanding and applying polyester resin such as gel coat. Thus far, we have not addressed the health hazards of working with these materials. I have been sanding without using even a comfort mask and the thought just occurred to me that this was maybe not a good idea. Does anyone have knowledge about this?
jimh posted 11-23-2002 12:56 PM ET (US)     Profile for jimh  Send Email to jimh     
Actually, in that article I don't mention wearing a respirator.

I wear an inexpensive disposable filter mask.

http://continuouswave.com/maintenance-logs/epoxy/

DJS posted 11-23-2002 02:37 PM ET (US)     Profile for DJS  Send Email to DJS     
I also wore a disposable filter mask when sanding. I worked on the keel area of a 22 Outrage and at times my face was almost where I was sanding. Here's a tip if you are working on a boat that is still on a trailer; use a mechanics creeper to get around while you are laying on your back. Of course this means you have to be parked on a hard surface. Sure beats dragging yourself over the ground.

David

Contender25 posted 11-23-2002 04:11 PM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
The more protective gear the better. I wear a respirator 3M, Tyvek suit and hood, glasses etc. I will try to find the model 3M respirator.
Sammy posted 11-24-2002 02:45 AM ET (US)     Profile for Sammy  Send Email to Sammy     
Contender25,

Lots of very good and very useful information - thanks! I have a 15' hull to shoot next spring (this winter if I can line up a heated work space) and this information will definitely help.

A few questions if you don't mind.

What type of gun did you use, who's the manufacturer and how well did it perform? From your description it sounds like you were using a cup gun, but that's just a guess. After shooting a few hulls, do you have any recommendations on guns. ES Mfg, Glas-Craft and BODI are just a few of the cup gun builders out there - any of them or others that make a better product? (BODI also makes the disposable Preval sprayer for small areas referenced by Taylor and Tom W. Clark in their excellent piece on fiberglass
repair.)

What size compressor are you using to push the gun? Is it adequate?

I'm assuming you stripped off all hardware and rubrail before shooting (duh?). What's your recommendation on how to deal with the brass through-hull fittings on a Whaler? Remove and replace even if they are in good shape? Taping wouldn't seem to be an effective option on a gelcoat shoot - but I don't know.

Thanks again. Your heads-up on the wax removing acetone wash prior to sanding and the Dye-Kem tip are just a couple of examples of why this is such a valuable site. sammy

DJS posted 11-24-2002 10:59 AM ET (US)     Profile for DJS  Send Email to DJS     
Sammy,

Two of the top producers of air compressors and spray equipment are:

www.binks.com and
www.devilbiss.com

If you go to these two sites you will find a lot of information pertaining to their products and how to use them

When selecting a conventional (as opposed to airles) spray gun you may use an internal-mix-nozzle or an external-mix-nozzle. Both may be used with a cup. An internal mix nozzle will usually require less air than a external mix nozzle. However, an external mix nozzle will produce a finer finish than the external nozzle. These air nozzles will require a certain amount of air to operate efficiently at a given air pressure.

In addition to the air nozzles, you will have a fluid nozzle. Fluid nozzles have orfices that regulate how much fluid may be applied at given time. You need to determine what size fluide nozzle is appropriate for the material being used, and then choose an air nozzle that will properly atomize the amount of fluid you are trying to apply.

Once you have determined the above you should then choose a compressor that will deliver enough cubic feet of air, and air pressure, to accomplish what you want to do. Most people, when choosing a compressor, want to know how much air pressure will the compressor put out. A better question is, will this compressor supply an adequate amount of air ( C.F.M.), at the pressures I need to perform the task.

Hope this helps.

David

Contender25 posted 11-24-2002 12:10 PM ET (US)     Profile for Contender25  Send Email to Contender25     
Hello Sammy-

The spray gun I used was from Crafstman, built for Crasftman by devilbiss. It is run of the mill, the gel-coat was put in the silver part of the gun that resides on the bottom of the gun. I am unsure but I think a cup gun is the type with a disposable cup that mounts on top of the gun?? If so I did not use a cup gun. I think Devilbiss manufactures most outh there, but I am not a spray gun guru.

I did not purchase anything special as the spraying part of gel-coating is not when I am concerned about finish. It is just how the gel-coat gets on the hull. Were I spraying Imron or AwlGrip I would be far more concerned with a quality gun because the application with the sprayer is your final finish.

The compresser again, Craftman, I do not have the model # but it is a 6hp and is more than I needed. When buying the gun the required aircomp specs are on it so all you have to do is match it all up.

The one thing I did not mention is I did use a water seperater inline with the spray gun. this is important, you do not want water contaminating your gel-coat.

On the boat I have sprayed thus far, I never had the brass thru-hull issue. Good Question. On the Mako 19, the owner did not want to remove the rub rail so we taped that up and removed the tape after the gel-coat had hardened. No problems. I just sanded in the tape lines and it came out surprisingly well.

Taping should work out ok.

Sammy posted 11-24-2002 12:34 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sammy  Send Email to Sammy     
David,

Thanks for the reply. I appreciate you taking the time.

The variables you listed regarding the gun and air/fluid nozzles (i.e. internal vs. external mix, size of fluid nozzle, etc.) are the specific types information I was trying to elicit from someone who has practical experience using the equipment. In other words, what specific equipment was used and how well did it perform. I probably didn't do a very good job of wording my original post.

As for compressors, I'm running three small portable pancakes that are great for framing, finish and siding/roofing nailers, but would be useless for this application. I also have a somewhat larger commercial grade portable with a SCFM rating of 8.1 @ 40 psi/6.4 @ 90 psi, 125 max psi, 20 gallon tank with a Doerr 5hp, 15 amp electric motor rated for continuous duty.

Equipment recommendations from the manufacturer are often right on the money. Other times there is a significant variation when it comes to practical/field/jobsite applications. Comparing pactical experience to manufacturers' recomendations can be very useful.

Spending money for necessary, quality equipment has always made good sense to me. Buying the wrong or unnecessary equipment is aggravating, buying crummy equipment is worse and all are a waste (I have a little of each that I have to look at almost daily) and avoiding mistakes is always a goal.

Thanks again, sammy.

Sammy posted 11-24-2002 12:52 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sammy  Send Email to Sammy     
Hi Contender25,

Appreciate the follow-up. So taping will work with gelcoat - that's great info. The in-line water separator is another good heads-up. If run-of-the-mill equipment does the trick, even better.

I was a little surprised about using 80 grit to prep the surface. Apparently 3 coats of gelcoat are enough to bridge that sort of surface. It ought to provide a good bite for the new material.

Thanks again for taking the time to post the step-by-step, terrific information. After reading through your posts it's pretty clear that final results are more front-end prep and back-end effort dependant than equipment dependant. If you interested, I'll let you know how it comes out. sammy

DJS posted 11-25-2002 09:29 AM ET (US)     Profile for DJS  Send Email to DJS     
Sammy,

I feel that I may need to clarify my previous message. I recommended that you look at the DeVilbiss and Bink websites because of the information that is available there, not to infer that you should buy their equipment instead of others.

The reason I elaborated so much on the different requirements of the spray guns, was so that you would not buy a compressor that wouldn't be adequate for what you may wish to do. I the past I have seen so many people go buy a relatively small, inexpensive, compressor and then wonder why they had to wait for the air supply to build back up before they could continue spraying. i.e., I have seen compressors rated at 1.5 to 2.5 SCFM being used with a spray gun that needed 4 to 6 SCFM to operate properly; you spray a little bit, wait for the pressure to build back up, then spray a little more, etc.

The compressor you already have "I also have a somewhat larger commercial grade portable with a SCFM rating of 8.1 @ 40 psi/6.4 @ 90psi" will most likely be adequate. As Contender 25 says, just choose a spray gun that will work with your compressor.

David

Post New Topic  Post Reply
Hop to:


Contact Us | RETURN to ContinuousWave Top Page

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Freeware Version 2000
Purchase our Licensed Version- which adds many more features!
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 2000.