|
Author
|
Topic: 2001 Optimax 150 Low Compression
|
|
adriano |
posted 05-17-2008 09:23 PM ET (US)
Hi guys. First post on this board. I was reading some messages and as they looked really good I thought I would join and ask your knowledgeable opinions.Here is the scenario: I have successfully mantained for 15 years a pair of carburetor 150-HP Black Max motors. To upgrade I have just bought a pair of secondhand 2001 150-HP OptiMax motors with Smartcraft. I have also bought a digital diagnostic tool (DDT) with Smartcraft v1.3 cartridge to mantain these engines.The engines are on stands in my workshop. The standard rotation engine is fine, compression before running it for the first time was approx 110-PSI on all cylinders. Got it started; sounds fine. Data monitor on the DDT seems all-OK. Will start servicing it soon so that it is ready to go. The counter rotation engine shows 405 hours and has a compression problem. Starboard side is OK; all cylinders are 110-PSI. Port side has the following reading 110, 30, 90 (from top cylinder down). Upon removal of the spark plugs, I noticed right away that the plug on the middle cylinder had some carbon build up on it and certainly this was different from all the other plugs. As the two cylinders with the problem are adjacents, I am hoping for a head gasket problem. Could this be due to some stuck rings? The engines have been stopped for a few months. Is there a simple way to do a leak tests for the head gasket? I thought of plugging the [pressure] gauge in the bottom cylinder and put air with a compressor in the middle one. If the bottom gauge moves would this confirm a problem with the head gasket? Should I try running the engine first and redo a compression test after? Should I spray some Power Tune (I used to use this in my old Black Max every 100 hours) in the two defective cylinders and let it sit overnight? Any help, tip or advise will be greatly appreciated.
|
|
Martino
|
posted 05-18-2008 12:39 AM ET (US)
90 pounds isn't horrible, but 30 pounds is. Best bet would be to pull the head on that bank. I would bet with those readings you will find the piston destroyed, and cylinder wall damaged. Hope I'm wrong and all you find is a bad head gasket. |
|
aussiejake
|
posted 05-18-2008 01:16 AM ET (US)
I hope you just have a gasket problem. I'm pretty sure that year motor ran O-rings rather than the conventional head gasket. Ssosmerc will clarify this. These are very cheap to replace compared to the older head gaskets.Don't worry too much either as it is an easy job. I did my 1999 135 OptiMax head gasket about a year ago. My compression was also down on one cylinder and the plug on that cylinder was always rusty and never burning properly. good luck Jake |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-18-2008 05:16 AM ET (US)
Martino and Jake, thanks for your replies.Jake, I am hoping to hear from sosmerc soon with his advise and I would also like to have a chat with you at a suitable time to describe in more details the removal and reassembly of the heads as well as getting the name of the guy who machined your head for $25. Martino, I was very disappointed too to see that low value. Actually I did the test with a friend and we both think the first time it actually read 0. Then we did the bottom cylinder (our last which read 90) and then retried for the middle one again that read 30. This change made has think of a sticky ring. The latest update is that I have now sprayed a full can of Power Tune 70% in the middle cylinder and 30% in the bottom one. While doing this we were constantly spinning the flywheel and I noticed that differently from my Black Max, in these OptiMax motors the Pistons move sideway of the Spark Plugs. Looking into the hole I could clearly see the pistons moving up and down and there is no strange noise or metallic sound. Everything sounds good. Also when I started squirting the Power Tune the bottom hole would regularly spit the oil back out at regular strokes while the middle one didn't. After having emptied 60% of the Can in the 2 cylinders I placed the spark plugs back in the two cylinders only and I cranked the engine a few times. I then removed the plugs again and continued emptying the remaining Power Tune in the two cylinders. Interesting enough, this time also the middle cylinder started spitting out some oil during the piston strokes. Am I dreaming here or is it just a coincidence? I was too concerned to be disappointed again by a low reading so I have decided to let everything sit overnight and I will retry a compression test tomorrow and update you on my findings. Wouldn't it be great to find the right compression? At this point I am not holding my breath. If somebody has any ideas of something else I should try please do not hesitate to mention it. Thanks again for your comments and I look forward to some more. Adriano |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-18-2008 05:57 AM ET (US)
Jake, I just checked the Service Manual. You are right, these Opti have 1 x Seal-Cylinder Head and 3 x Seal-Cylinder Bore that look like O-Rings. Is it conceivable that just a bad O-Ring can create this great compression lost? |
|
aussiejake
|
posted 05-18-2008 06:38 AM ET (US)
The top of my head gasket was stuffed causing the top port piston (number two) to read around 60 pounds from memory. The others were around 120.I would say one bad O-ring would allow the cylinder to drop dramatically just like a normal blown head gasket. I had 15-thousandths machined off the head, the manual recommends 5-thousandths maximum. Mine has been running well now for the past year with 750 hours on the clock, so I'm not too concerned about the extra 10-thousandths. cheers Jake |
|
aussiejake
|
posted 05-18-2008 06:51 AM ET (US)
I would give you the name of the guy who machined it but I'm in South Australia. I can give you a complete run down of my repair if you want. Head removal only takes about an hour, and thats carefully removing all the bits :) Jake |
|
aussiejake
|
posted 05-18-2008 07:03 AM ET (US)
I just read your email Adriano and realised your in Adelaide as well. |
|
lurkynot
|
posted 05-18-2008 12:56 PM ET (US)
I did the port head for a different reason last summer. As aussiejake said it was a piece of cake. 17 bolts including the 12 head bolts and of course several electrical connectors.Get a jump on ordering the bore seals and head gasket 4 parts total for each head. It was the longest part of the job - just getting the parts. The head seal was delivered in a week out of Fon Du Lac as promised however the bore seals came out of California probably from an overseas supplier to Mercury 2 weeks later. The service manual was a big help. Bought a disk off of eBay gave about 22 dollars with shipping. Also get brand new head bolts and follow the sequences for unbolting and again when reinstalling them. Below I have included a link of the head after removal. Not sure if that thread includes all the picture I took. However I do have plenty if you need a specific shot of something. Those digital were a great aid in routing hoses and connectors especially after the delay in the parts order. Good luck. Tony http://continuouswave.com/ubb/Forum3/HTML/013567.html |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-18-2008 06:40 PM ET (US)
I got this message from sosmerc ......I think you need to pull your heads and examine the condition of the piston tops and cylinder walls. Maybe you will get lucky and find bad cylinder o-rings. If you also pull the exhaust cover and divider plate you can get a good luck at the condition of the piston rings and piston skirts through the exhaust port. With the heads off you can also check for "play" in the rod bearings. Bring the piston up to TDC and then move it a bit more past TDC, hold the flywheel still and push in on the piston...there should not be much play or movement. Hopefully you have the correct factory manual. There is a wealth of information in there. All that is needed beyond that is time, money, and patience. Good luck with your project...keep us posted!
|
|
adriano
|
posted 05-18-2008 07:35 PM ET (US)
Hi Tony and thank you for your reply. I have 2 motors on stand side by side, fortunately one works great! :-) and I can use as reference for the routing which is already providing great help while working on my new two motors. I would regardless love to get as many of the pictures you took as possible. They will still be of added help I am sure. I have sent you an email with my details for sending these. The Parts I need are 1 x 858452 x $22 and 3 x 859772 x $10ea. In regards to the 12 Bolts 10 878217 x $5.95ea (the above are US$ prices) are you suggesting I get these 12 new as well? If so why? |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-18-2008 07:51 PM ET (US)
sosmerc, thanks again for your input, always greatly appreciated.As I already mentioned I will regardless quickly run again a compression test in 7 hours but I am not holding my breath. Even if the compression improves unless I get over 90 on the middle as well I will proceed with the removal of the port head. In the case of the compression having improved considerably, say from 30 to over 60, would it be worth firing them and running some decarb like Ring Free or Quick Klean before disassembling the head? Also as I have a DDT, should I be checking something specific to better help diagnose what could have happened to these cylinders? Any specific info or faults you would like me to jot down? Remember that I am new to the DDT but also I am very good with technology stuff so I can be a very quick learner and I already have a fair idea of what to do with it after only 2 days of playing time :-) |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-18-2008 07:52 PM ET (US)
BTW, Serial No for these engines is approx OT390000 |
|
sosmerc
|
posted 05-18-2008 08:59 PM ET (US)
Using the DDT you can review the run history. It would be interesting to see what the "history" shows in terms of overheat, over-rev, oil pump faults, etc. You can also initiate an "auto test". This is done with the key on, but engine not running. If there is multiple cylinder damage I would be concerned about an oiling issue...especially if you detect rod bearing failure or wrist pin failure. Have you written down run history for each engine? Also, just FYI...2000 and 2001 models were the first to use Smartcraft and they require the "Smarttach and Smartspeed" guages rather than the SC1000 series guages. 2002 Optimax engines can use any of the current Smartcraft Guages. All I am saying is that you may have to be sure whatever guages you decide to use are compatible with your Model Year 2001 engines. The DDT will be fine with any of the Optimax engines to date. |
|
lurkynot
|
posted 05-18-2008 09:47 PM ET (US)
Yes Adriano. All 12 brand new. When reinstalling the original ones there is always the chance one may twist off while being torqued for a second time. This is your call of course. sosmerc or aussiejake may be able to chime in on this detail as to whether or not it is worth the expense. |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-18-2008 10:00 PM ET (US)
sosmerc, great to hear from you again. These engines are definetely Smrtcraft. I will re-run the DDT again tonight and post all readings again later on. I did do it before cranking for compression and this is what I had written down, at this stage I have not added any oil in the engine little tank and I have not done any Fuel or Oil priming routines (I have done all of this to the other engine to get it running):After Auto Self Test OIL RESERVE STB YES PITOT INPUT LO YES OIL LVL IN HI MPRLY OUTPUT NO FUEL LVL IN HI YES SEA TMP IN HI YES TRIM INPUT LO YES After RUN History 0-749 72.3 750-1499 44.6 1500-2999 25.8 3000-3999 20.1 4000-4499 12.5 4500-4999 21.2 5000-5499 16.7 5500-6249 0.7 6250- 0 BREAK LEFT 0 RPM LIMIT 0 CTP TMP 17 LOW OIL COUNTING as I had no oil OIL PUMP 0 That is all I had down. there was another list but I missed it on this engine, I will update later GRD LIMIT ACT TEMP BLOCK PSI CTS TMP If you need any other data specifically or want me to run any of the Manual Tests please ask me. As far as the Gauges are concerned I do have 2 per engine Square digital gauge which skips through all readings Trim Gauge - SmartCraft connector Although this gauges power up and I can scan through the various modes, I cannot get them to read values. But this is of no concern to me yet as I have been able to use the DDT under Data Monitor to monitor all values of the other engine. I will get to this when I have both engine running correctly. |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-19-2008 06:45 AM ET (US)
sosmerc, I met aussiejake today and we went down to check the engines together. The good news is that the bottom cylinder has now got 110 compression as well. The bad news is that the middle one is always sitting at 30. aussiejake noticed that the top of the piston looks cleaner than the other 5. He also tried gently to move the piston with a screwdriver from the plug hole hoping for a sticking ring but could not get any movement. No unusual sound or problem. For a moment we contemplated trying to run the engines, but our final conclusion is that we feel the O ring is gone. Let's hope so. I will be starting the disassembly of the port head tomorrow and keep everyone posted on the progress.I also replugged the ddt in and somehow ( I could not figure out what I have left disconnected) I got EST6 to EST1 OPEN NO while I had not seen this Fault before during the Auto Self Test. I must have left something disconnected even though I could not find it!!! So here is the update info from the DDT: FAULT HISTORY OIL RSV STR YES EST6 OPEN NO EST5 OPEN NO EST4 OPEN NO EST3 OPEN NO EST2 OPEN NO EST1 OPEN NO PITOT INPUT LO YES OIL LVL IN LO YES MPRLY OUTPUT NO FUEL LVL IN HI YES SEA TEMP IN HI YES TRIM INPUT LO YES the eight check light look like this off on off off off off on off RUN HISTORY is the same as in my previous post plus the following missed values GRD LIMIT sec 43 ACT TEMP sec 118 BLOCK PSI sec 15 CTS TMP sec 142 I then proceded to check the FAULT SECONDS BATT VOLT HIGH sec O BATT VOLT LOW sec O BLOCK PSI LOW sec 15 COMP OVERHEAT sec 118 ETC STICKING sec O ETC CONTROL sec O FUEL PSI IN sec O OIL PSI STR sec O OIL REM STR sec O OIL RES STR sec counting MAP INPUT HI sec O MAP INPUT LO sec O MAP IDLE CHECK sec O OVERSPEED sec O PORT OVERHEAT sec 17 STAR OVERHEAT sec 142 WARN HORN sec 0 H2O IN FUEL 46K This is all I got from the DDT.
Please let me know if you see anything unusual.
|
|
aussiejake
|
posted 05-19-2008 08:05 AM ET (US)
after looking onto the top of the piston with a torch and seeing the polished crown I would say it has been washed clean with water. It looks very much like mine did, minus the rusty spark plug. Hopefully it's just a perished O ring. I'm sure Adriano will find out as soon as he removes the head.Jake. |
|
sosmerc
|
posted 05-19-2008 10:55 AM ET (US)
Looks like the engine got pretty hot at some point...hot enough to go into Guardian Mode. That's probably what instigated the failure. |
|
sosmerc
|
posted 05-19-2008 11:01 AM ET (US)
The DDT data also indicates the engine had water in the fuel at some point, and ran out of oil in the main tank and was running on reserve oil. Be sure to clear the fault history and re-examine after initial running. You will want to carefully examine your thermostats when the heads are off, and I assume you will be starting out with a fresh water pump impeller.
|
|
adriano
|
posted 05-19-2008 06:32 PM ET (US)
sosmerc, what data in the ddt makes you realize that it got pretty hot at some time and that it went into Guardian mode? |
|
sosmerc
|
posted 05-19-2008 09:29 PM ET (US)
Under the fault seconds you listed: Block PSI Low...means low water pressure Comp Overheat...means the compressor was overheating Port Overheat...means the Port Head was overheating Star Overheat...means the Starboard Head was overheating H20 in Fuel...means water in the engine mounted fuel filterOverheating for even a short time can be very hard on piston rings and cylinder walls...might not do the cylinder O-rings any good either. |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-19-2008 09:45 PM ET (US)
sosmerc, all clear.With aussiejake yesterday we thought that has the STR overheated much longer than the PORT if a damage had to occurr due to this issue it would have been on that side and not the port one. I am off to the workshop now and I should have the head off by tonight. Will keep you posted. I am so looking forward to find a badly perished O-Ring! Thanks again for your great help. |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-20-2008 09:13 AM ET (US)
OK, here are my findings ....There was nothing wrong with the O-Rings or gasket. The piston seems badly pitted and it has some considerable wear on the front edge in several degrees of the circumference. In one spot in particular there seems to be a 2mm chip missing on the edge as well. The cylinder is scored, not deeply but certainly enough to require honing. The last issue is with the head, inside the domed part where the plug whole is there is a lot of pitting and it feels very rough to the touch. I have starting disassembling the powerhead and I am planning a rebuild. I have seen this rebuild kit on ebay, what do you guys think? http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=260239763816 I will organized some more detailed pictures tomorrow, in the meantime I would be curious to hear your opinion. In particular to the cause. The last thing I would like to do is to rebuild it only to find that it will fail again after a short time. In assesing it with some friends we felt as if there had been a piece of metal sitting in there being slammed around. Could it possibly have been a broken piece from a spark plug? a defect in the casting of the piston? or will I find a broken ring? hopefully the will not be to much damage behind the piston. |
|
Tohsgib
|
posted 05-20-2008 10:31 AM ET (US)
Yep..she ran lean and detonated. Crank and all should be good considering there is not do too much damage...but enough. |
|
sosmerc
|
posted 05-20-2008 11:20 AM ET (US)
Sorry to hear the bad news. Check the direct injectors carefully...you may have had one come apart. However, since more than one cylinder was affected, I suspect a cooling or oiling issue. Don't forget to run a compression test on the air compressor as well...as it also needs cooling and oiling. These are expensive engines to rebuild properly, so you really want to be sure and check out everything before going back together. I'd send all the injectors out for cleaning and flow testing. Have a dealer run the serial number and see if all the "update" work had been done to that motor. If I recall correctly, there were a number of service bulletins on 2.5 litre models around you year model. Keep us posted. |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-21-2008 02:50 AM ET (US)
thanks for the input tohsjib. sosmerc, I will test the injectors carefully before reinstalling. I think I will need a specific tool (Gearcase Leakege Tool FT-8950) and a normal Ohm Test to do this. How do I do a compression test on the Compressor??? I do have all the service bulletins on these engines, I downloaded before even getting the engines. There isn't anything major required. I will keep you posted. From tonight I will be filming my work and I will upload to youtube later in several parts once the project is completed. Please let me know about the compression test on the compressor. Also did you check the rebuild kit? What do you think? Is it a good quality one or can you recommend something else? Thanks a lot, Adri |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-21-2008 10:33 AM ET (US)
Ok, the powerhead is off. Good news is that all other cylinders look perfect. Bad news is that I need to identify what has gone wrong in order to prevent it after the rebuild. After the removal of the head yesterday it was obvious that there must have been a piece of metal sitting in front of the piston and slamming into the head. The piston was badly pitted, chipped and worn on the edges. Here is a picture of the middle headhttp://www.artsmagna.com/fishing_aus/head.jpg As you can see there is metal marks into it. Before removing the Exaust plate we had a theory of the rings having broken but after further inspection we have noticed that the rings were still ok. At this point we had thought that possibly a mechanic had dropped a plug, fitted it anyway and this had ended up breaking the little tip in the cylinder and caused all the damage. What instead we were not prepared to discover is what we have found after the removal of the reeds plate
http://www.artsmagna.com/fishing_aus/reeds1.jpg http://www.artsmagna.com/fishing_aus/reeds2.jpg http://www.artsmagna.com/fishing_aus/reeds3.jpg The reed group that leads into the port middle cylinder had all the reeds completely smashed. How can this happen? We thought maybe the pieces of metal coming from the cylinder had traveled back into the reeds area and smashed the reeds? But this did not make sense has the flow would have been traveling in the opposite direction. Also unusual is the fact the the reed group just below, going to the STR bank, also had one only petal broken. Then we thought maybe something accidentally left on the AIR HANDLER ASSEMBLY had fallen into the assembly itself and eventually worked itself into the reeds. But in this case we feel it should have gone through the bottom group and not the third up from the bottom! Can someone please shed some light and explain how the reeds could have broken leading to such a catastrophic failure!!! Is it possible that these reeds are the actual pieces of metals that once reached the cylinder area between the piston and the head have created this massive problem? I would certainly say so but I would like to understand how can this happen? sosmerc, also a reminder that I need urgently to buy the rebuild kit and I would like your opinion on the kit I have found on ebay http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ih=016&sspagename=STRK%3AMEWA%3AIT&viewitem=&item=260239763816&rd=1 Do you think this would be a good quality kit? Can you recommend or sell me a similar or better set? Also I have a chance to buy on ebay a reed plate complete with reeds from a 2003 used 150 optimax engine at $50 plus delivery. Is it worth me buying it? Should I trust second hand reeds. Should I trust the ones I have left and not broken on my plate? I look forward to your comments so that I can start rebuilding this engine asap and get on the water. |
|
sosmerc
|
posted 05-21-2008 11:57 AM ET (US)
I have no experience with "rebuild kits" as I generally order oem parts and get just what I need for the job. So I have no way to preperly evaluate the kit shown...I don't know who has manufactured the parts. You could use a website such as iShopMarine.com to piece together a similar kit and see how their prices compare. It is possible that this engine had reed failure and that lead to a lean condition. Reed material flying around in the crankcase and the cylinders will do serious damage as you can see. You may want to consider using Boyesen fibre reeds for your rebuild. If they break they can go through your engine without causing damage. Since this is a major project I would assume you are going to strip the crank down and examine the bearing surfaces? I would recommend sending your injectors to Tony Brucato for evaluation and cleaning. But you can look them over carefully with a manifying glass to see if they are missing any parts in the tip area...or if it appears any loose metal has been jammed into the injectors. The air compressor compression is checked by blocking off or pinching off the excess air outlet hose, hooking up a pressure guage to the air pressure test fitting and then cranking the engine over. It should be capable of producing over 110 PSI.
|
|
adriano
|
posted 05-21-2008 04:39 PM ET (US)
Thanks sosmerc,I will check the iShopMarine site later today. Will certainly consider the Boyesen fibre reeds. I will certainly be examining the bearing surfaces. As I am in Australia I think, sending the injectors to Tony Brucato is a bit complex, I think I will rather get the tool mentioned and do a flow test and an ohm test myself. Plus I will examin with a magnifing glasss as you mentioned. I also now understand how to check the compression on the compressor. Still a question remains unanswered .... what can cause the reeds to fail so badly??? Is this a time bomb sitting in everyone's optimax? should I check the other engine's reeds as well? have you ever seen this problem before and why do you think it occurred??? |
|
sosmerc
|
posted 05-21-2008 05:52 PM ET (US)
I would consider it rare...I have never seen it on any Optimax engine yet. It surprises me especially since it appears your reed blocks are rubber coated. Sudden over-reving is generally what gets to reeds over time.....but, maybe the engine sat idle with moisture from condensation causing some rust to form on the reeds and this weakened them......this is pure speculation. Your fault codes indicated water in the fuel at one time, but this water/fuel goes directly into the cylinders without passing by the reeds as all conventional carb and efi motors do. Denting or smashing of the reed blocks can occur when a rod bolt lets go and debris gets between the rod and the reed blocks while swinging around. (there's not a whole lot of clearance). Carefully check to see if there are any signs of rod contact with the sides of the crankcase. It is certainly possible that something went through the engine and that started a chain of unfortunate events. |
|
adriano
|
posted 05-21-2008 06:31 PM ET (US)
sosmerc, while we speculate (and this will be the last of my speculations, is it possible that pieces of metal (a broken piece of spark plug that chips the piston) hitting the piston and head can travel back from the cylinder through the crankcase and onto the reeds? |