posted 12-04-2009 09:43 AM ET (US)
Also rotate the prop shaft while pushing forward on it to get a feel for the front main bearings that carry the bulk of the load. They should feel smooth. Side to side play should be minimal, front to back play is often evident - specifications would have to come from a shop manualAt least a visual check should be made for prop shaft straightness. Stare straight at the end of the shaft - often there's a slight dimple in the center of the shaft you can focus on, then grab a propeller blade and give the shaft a spin (in neutral). Look for any wobble.
Check for bent/broken skegs.
Draining and refilling the gearcase is obviously the best way to go but because it's messy, time consuming, and the owner may not want you to do it, I often simply crack open the lower drain plug and see what comes out. If the engine has not been run or even cranked in awhile, any water in the gearcase will have settled to the bottom and be first to come out. I always ask my sellers to please not crank the engine prior to my check-out visit just for this reason. The gearcase is then checked first before ever spinning the engine for the various other checks needed.
If the seller has just changed, very recently changed the fluid, obviously determining gearcase health via fluid inspection is futile. Gearcase fluid will turn dark as it's used. It will also start to emit a fairly strong, foul odor. This is all normal and expected.
The pressure and vacuum checks JimH referred to are an excellent way to assess gear case seal health. Typically 3-5 psi is used to check the seal lips against their mating shafts. 15 psi is usually used to check the seal case seal integrity (outer metal ring of the seal). All pressure and vacuum readings should hold steady for 15 minutes. Drive and propeller shafts should be spun some by hand during the test. Some shop manuals skip the 3-5 psi test and skip straight to the 15 psi test. This can have the effect of pressing a lip-to-shaft seal location into sealing when under normal operating pressures, it would not seal properly.