Forum: WHALER
  ContinuousWave
  Whaler
  Moderated Discussion Areas
  ContinuousWave: Whaler Repairs/Mods
  Switching from built in to portable fuel tanks?

Post New Topic  Post Reply
search | FAQ | profile | register | author help

Author Topic:   Switching from built in to portable fuel tanks?
Sheila posted 02-21-2005 07:05 PM ET (US)   Profile for Sheila   Send Email to Sheila  
This post is in follow to my post about the issues with the hours (and costs!) at our local fuel dock.

It seems that the safest, workable situation suggested in that thread was to pick up a couple of portable 12 gallon tanks. That way the installed tank could be kept full (no condensation issues) and we could run off the portables. Every so often of course we'd use the installed tank's gas, then refill it to keep the gas in there fresh.

What kind of fittings might one install to switch between the permanent and portable tanks? Thanks!

linust posted 02-21-2005 07:18 PM ET (US)     Profile for linust  Send Email to linust     
"portable" 12 gallon tanks weigh about 90# each, full...plus they take up a fair amount of deck space (thinking about your seating thread). you sure you want to go this route?
newport jack posted 02-21-2005 07:31 PM ET (US)     Profile for newport jack    
Sheila, I've been watching your postings about the gas dock and such, couple things:
1.) You can use portable tanks by having a bulb and hose on the portable tank with the right fuel fitting on to match right to your engine, then just swap the fittings and prime you fuel line and go.
2.) Don't worry about the condesation, most posters said they never had problems. Your boat will use more gas when driving on those portable tanks with a full tank below decks, 145 gallons is a lot of weight. My feelings are that anything over 12 gallons isn't portable and is heavy as heck to carry. Running the small tanks will put you at risk of running out of gas at the wrong time or just running your engine out of gas and lube.
You have a great boat in the water that you can hop in and take out anytime, do you really want to ruin that by running to the gas station and hauling tanks of gas down to your boat. That said I think it's time for another toast to your boat, I have to go get another Yuengling Lager....Jack
Sheila posted 02-21-2005 08:04 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
Linust, you have stumbled across my diabolical plot. So--we pull the livewell and boat for a bit without it (which, by the way, will lighten the boat by about the exact amount that the two 12 gallon tanks, full, would weigh). Then we try the portable tanks. Once he sees the savings (they would pay for themselves after about 4 rounds of use, if we bought 2), we fabricate a stern seat that the two tanks fit neatly beneath. My husband really burns up at paying a dollar a gallon more at the docks.

Jack, I understand your point. I can't lift 90 pounds, but my husband is a wiry guy and can do it easily. We're picturing leaving the main tank about half full (since condensation isn't an issue) and periodically using that gasoline to keep the gas in the tank fresh. I'm also picturing a fitting arrangement wherein we could switch from the portable tanks to the installed one, thus running out of gas wouldn't be an issue.

What am I missing?

JOHN W MAYO posted 02-21-2005 08:44 PM ET (US)     Profile for JOHN W MAYO  Send Email to JOHN W MAYO     
A selector switch is easy to install. Using quick disconect fitting makes it easy to change tanks. I do no not like the price of fuel at the docks.

I have 2-13 gallon, and 1-27 gallon, tanks I sometime have on board (not at the same time) in addition to my inboard 40 gallon tank.

I trailer the boat so it is easy to refuel. By having a little extra fuel I can leave it in the water for 2 to 3 days of fishing or travel longer distances. I burn out of the small tanks, then remove the empty tanks from the boat at the end of the day.

If you are considering filling 13 gallon tanks and carrying them to the dock I do not recommend it. It is heavy, but it is very awkard to carry full.

newport jack posted 02-21-2005 09:43 PM ET (US)     Profile for newport jack    
Well it sounds like you are going with portable tanks, so figure out how big, those 12 gallon tanks are going to get heavy. I have a Revenge now , but had a Newport with twin 9 gallon tanks, I'm 6ft, 215lbs., and those tanks get heavy while you are walking with it on your shoulder. You will need one fuel line with a primer bulb in it with the proper end fittings, run on a tank until it is empty then swap over to second tank. Another thing when you are carrying those tanks make sure the vent is screwed shut, I didn't one time and was soaked in gas, not kool. Whatever you do you won't be wasting much money or time, and if you get the desire to make a long distance run , reserve tanks are a nice idea.............Jack
JOHN W MAYO posted 02-21-2005 10:18 PM ET (US)     Profile for JOHN W MAYO  Send Email to JOHN W MAYO     
They make "fuel catties" sp,
tanks with wheels on them that you roll down o the dock and fill your tank...cost about 200.
I think BassPro sells them along with Boaters World , etc.
2004_130_SPORT posted 02-21-2005 10:26 PM ET (US)     Profile for 2004_130_SPORT  Send Email to 2004_130_SPORT     
sheila, didnt you say in an earlier topic that your marina wont let you fill you own tanks due to "polluition" (or the just want you to buy their gas) so that gets rid of the caddie idea and those things arent good when you have to lift then into the car or truck.
Joe Kriz posted 02-21-2005 10:49 PM ET (US)     Profile for Joe Kriz  Send Email to Joe Kriz     
Sheila, (with a She)

Question?
Do your engines have "Quick Dissconnects" on them now?
If not, then you might want to check your engine manual on the use of these.
Many 150hp engines and above want you to use a solid connection.
This is due to the higher volume of fuel running through the lines along with more pressure from larger fuel pumps.

Check your manual or with a mechanic that know your engines.

For my 1985 Evinrude 150hp, there are NO "Quick Dissconnects"...
These are Not Recommended for 150hp and above OMC's.

Yours may vary.. Caution.

Sheila posted 02-21-2005 11:47 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
Evan, yes--good memory. It's the "fuel dock dilemma" thread over in GAM. This thread is an outgrowth of that one.

Joe :)
Thank you for bringing that up. I will look through my owner's manual again, though my usual reaction to reading it is frustration with the lack of detail provided therein.

In my little dream world, I believe I was picturing a valve into the existing fuel line that when activated would "cut off" the main tank and "open" the portable one. I was picturing a fitting to attach the portable fuel tank's line to this valve. Is there no such fitting?

Sheila posted 02-22-2005 12:10 AM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
Oh, and Jack? Our thinking was that the portable tanks are inexpensive enough that we could "try it out." If we hate it, then we sell them, take our losses, and go back to relying on the dock and its schedule. And I'd imagine we'd use a cart to move them from the car to the boat...
LHG posted 02-23-2005 07:07 PM ET (US)     Profile for LHG    
What am I missing about buying six 6-gallon portable plastic gas cans at Walmart, and filling the boat tank from them?
JMARTIN posted 02-23-2005 07:52 PM ET (US)     Profile for JMARTIN  Send Email to JMARTIN     
LHG, no fueling on your own over the dock. Man, this seems like alot of work. You would save 24 bucks over the marina fuel. The tanks would be at least 100 pounds. You have to go to the gas station each time. The explosive power of 2 "empty" 12 gallon tanks is enormous. If I remember correctly, you have a van. Get use to gasoline fumes. Some stations will frown on you filling tanks in the vehicle, they want you to "ground" them. How many gallons an hour do you burn? Does the marina have summer hours that will work better for your schedule? Can you get a gas cattie or what ever they are called and play dumb? John
Sheila posted 02-23-2005 08:39 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
John, we've talked about the "playing dumb" part....if I knew with some certainty how severe the penalty was for a first offense, I would be more comfortable. This marina is the only one within 20 miles of our home. I'd hate to be banned.
where2 posted 02-23-2005 10:19 PM ET (US)     Profile for where2  Send Email to where2     
There is a defense for the 12 gallon tanks, it's the kicker motor on the transom.

As for plumbing the 12 gallon tanks into the main system, that will get interesting. I have a "3-way" valve on my 15' Sport to swap between my two 6-gallon tanks and the engine.

Since I have recently been troubleshooting my own fuel delivery problems, I can tell you what I know. If you go the "quick connect" route, you will want to plumb a vacuum gauge into the fuel delivery (suction) hose near the engine to determine whether you are starving the engine. OMC recommends no more than 5.5" of mercury on the V4 engines, and not more than 7" of mercury on the V6 engine fuel inlet hose. Yamaha should have a similar specification which you should pay particular attention to when running from non-factory tanks. OMC specifies 3/8" I.D. hose is "required" for V6 engines.

Shiela, Are there no public launch ramps locally that your husband could meet you at with a car-load of 5-gallon fuel cans?

Sheila posted 02-23-2005 11:30 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
Where2, the launch ramp is inside the same marina...hmm...I'd imagine if we got "caught" doing that, the consequences would be the same as whatever they might be right in our slip.
Phil Tyson posted 02-24-2005 09:10 AM ET (US)     Profile for Phil Tyson  Send Email to Phil Tyson     
Sheila -

Here is more food for thought.

When fueling portables tanks (not in a boat) at a gas station, you want to remove them and put them on the ground. Don't get back in your van after starting to fuel.

I recently saw a story on tv showing several people fueling cars where static electricity started a fire. In one segment, a person started fueling using the clip on the nozzle to auto-fill and then went back and sat in the car.When they got out and touched the nozzle, Woosh!.

There was a guy with a pickup. He had plastic gas cans in the back. When he touched the nozzle to one of the tanks in the bed, Woosh! (The tanks slid across a plastic bed liner on the trip to the station building up a charge.)

To get around your wacked Marina -

Buy a caddy with wheels. Buy a large duffle bag or similar size bag to camoflauge the caddy. Cut holes for the wheels and handle. Go off motoring and transfer fuel away from dock into your main tank.

For the weight issue, get a set of those aluminum ramps so you can get the caddy in and out of your van.

Don't forget the cost savings of buying gas on land vs marina.

I trailer and fuel at a local station and save $0.50 or more on every gallon of gas.

If none of this sounds appealing, consider moving to another marina. I think they may have lower slip fees since they only sell $$$$ gas.

jeffs22outrage posted 02-24-2005 09:35 AM ET (US)     Profile for jeffs22outrage  Send Email to jeffs22outrage     
http://www.westmarine.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/ProductDisplay?storeId=10001&langId=-1&catalogId=10001&productId=81040
jeffs22outrage posted 02-24-2005 09:41 AM ET (US)     Profile for jeffs22outrage  Send Email to jeffs22outrage     
The fuel costs are just part of owning a boat. I hate paying $.70 -$1.00 more a gallon on water than land but that is that. Trust me the fueling, hauling, and filling of the small tanks will get old really fast. You are probaly better off putting the boat on a trailer once a week and fill up on land if you can.
banff22 posted 02-24-2005 11:57 AM ET (US)     Profile for banff22  Send Email to banff22     
I agree, I think the novelty of hauling your own fuel to save will be over quickly. Just the thought of it is a determent to go for a ride on a nice afternoon. It seems to ruin the whole point of paying for a slip versus a trailer. Possibly another marina, even if it is a longer drive, may be easier than all this.

I'm curious. I think this discussion is in California (Sheila) and I'm wondering...what is the price of fuel at the gas station and what is it at a marina in Califirnia. And is there much of a difference across the U.S.?

Regards,
Peter

banff22 posted 02-24-2005 12:27 PM ET (US)     Profile for banff22  Send Email to banff22     
Never mind. Changed my glasses;-) and I just found Sheila's fuel dock thread with the info. It was much further down than I had searched.

I wanted to compare to Canada's prices in the Toronto area. Today's gas pump price is 80 CAN cents a litre.

1 US gallon = 3.78 litres
1 CAN $ = 1.24 US $ today

Peter

Sheila posted 02-24-2005 08:28 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
Peter, both marinas we've been in have had this regulation. I don't think moving would help. Maybe it's a California thing.

And, BTW, it wouldn't be me hauling the tanks. My husband's the one who's so bent over the pricing at the fuel dock. He's also the one with the body strength to move those things.

thekidd posted 02-25-2005 05:06 PM ET (US)     Profile for thekidd  Send Email to thekidd     
Convert built-in to portable? What?
Gas it up at the dock. Go when it's not busy.
It's a boat in a marina, you're going to have to pay more for gas and wait in line a bit longer then at a 76 station. Welcome to boat ownership!
Remember..... "BOAT" ...stands for Bring On Another Thousand! Or nowadays it's spelled with two t's BOATT...Ten Thousand
whalersailer posted 02-25-2005 05:38 PM ET (US)     Profile for whalersailer  Send Email to whalersailer     
Seems to me that if you're going to be using around 24 gallons per trip (give or take), then your 148 gallon tank would last 4-5 trips?

Why not just pull the boat out when she gets low on fuel and drive it to a gas station to fill up, then re-launch when done? I am certain that the time and trouble spent doing this will be less than messing with the "portable" 12 gallon tanks for those same trips - not to mention the safety factor mentioned by several above.

I guess I must be missing something here.

Also, it is a general restriction with most marina's I've seen that you can only take on fuel at the fuel dock, as this is the only area equipped to detect and deal with spills.

-WS

WT posted 02-25-2005 05:56 PM ET (US)     Profile for WT  Send Email to WT     
I would not recommend transporting fuel or having above deck fuel tanks if the boater is a smoker. The cuddy might trap gas vapors too.

I admit that I smoke cigars while I fish in the open waters with my Montauk. I have been told that I probably should not smoke when I carry 2 additional fuel tanks when I run for tuna.

My 2 cents.

Warren

LHG posted 02-25-2005 06:18 PM ET (US)     Profile for LHG    
It is easy to rig the permanent fuel lines for use of auxiliary tanks if needed, even if the engine has a permanent fuel line connection.

Tempo make a 3-way selector valve, which can be mounted so the handle is exposed and accessible. This allows an engine to draw fuel from either of two tanks, based on selector position. In most cases, it is inserted in the fuel line coming from the main tank, just before the water separating filter. One position thus selects the main tank. On the other selector intake fitting, a portable fuel line is clamped on, with a tank connect on the other end. This is then plugged into a portable red tank, and that line is selected for draw. When not being used, this aux fuel hose is coiled up under the gunwale, transom deck, etc.

If it is not necessary for the aux tank fuel to be drawn through the filter, the Tempo valve tap can be done between the filter and the engine.

I agree that lugging filled 12 gallon tanks into the boat will get old fast, a real back breaker becasue of their awkward configuration. It might be better to buy 4 or 6 of the $15 6 gallon tanks, the ones with the handles on them. Just put them in the boat as needed, depending on length of trip planned. Nor would I keep the main tank filled, because of the weight. 30 gallons in it would be enough for emergencies, if needed

Sheila posted 02-25-2005 10:07 PM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
WS, thanks for the thought. We do not own a trailer, nor a vehicle adequate to pull our boat. So it's a bit impractical.

Kidd, last time we were at the fuel dock, we waited 20 minutes and no other boats were there. The operator explained that he was on an important phone call. It's strictly "full service," which would be fine, except that by the time the boat was filled, he was on another call and we waited another ten minutes for him to take our money from us. I wouldn't object to a premium price if the service were even mediocre. My husband, however, while generous, is, um, frugal. And he's willing to expend some effort to save some money. We've had the boat out twice so far this week, and I'm sure we'll be out again tomorrow, so the $1.00/gallon difference could add up over time.

Larry, thank you for the simple explanation of how to do the required plumbing, if my husband decides to go this route.

elaelap posted 02-26-2005 12:52 AM ET (US)     Profile for elaelap  Send Email to elaelap     
I'm a SERIOUS cheapskate when it comes to looking for good gas prices, at least for my truck. However, and it's a huge however, Sheila, I'd happily pay an extra buck per gallon for my boat rather than jump through the hoops described above. Problems that I see in some of the suggested solutions include:

--Danger of personal injury, death, and loss of 'Little Whale' caused by fire during transportation of gasoline or when fueling at the dock from small containers.

--Angering the powers that be (and perhaps some of your neighbors) at the commercial dock; possibility of losing your slip.

--Extra hassles on board re the fuel delivery system; possibility of breakdowns at sea are increased.

--Loss of that GOOD weight below if you don't keep your regular tank pretty much filled up.

--Big WASTE OF cruising/fishing TIME for relatively small savings.

I'm not always very good at doing a realistic cost/benefit analysis about my boating habits; in fact, I impulse buy stuff I really don't need, sometimes run all over the place looking for fish when I should just be quietly trolling along in one location with my lines in the water, often pay a mechanic for fairly simple diagnostic and repair work I could easily do myself, etc. But one thing I know for sure...my TIME on and off the water is much more valuable than the cost of fuel, all other things considered. I'm glad I don't have to deal with your annoying and relatively expensive problem, but in context of the other costs of boating, especially with a large boat such as yours, I think I'd try hard to ignore it as a somewhat costly nuisance, buy my gas at the inflated marina prices, and just enjoy the ocean.

A real alternative would be to look around for a decent used trailer and an old beater $4000 V-8 pickup, and as several folks have suggested above, just haul your boat out every couple of weeks and fill 'er up for a more reasonable cost. Having a trailer opens up all kinds of possibilities perhaps more important than gas prices, such as saving substantial bucks on haul-outs, bottom painting and hull repairs, occasional trips to distant harbors, and long term dry storage if necessary.

Tony

andygere posted 02-26-2005 02:16 AM ET (US)     Profile for andygere  Send Email to andygere     
Buying gas at the gas dock is like buying beer at the ballpark. Sure, you can get beer much cheaper at the supermarket and drink it in your living room, but you won't be at the game, enjoying the sights, sounds and experience of being at the game. Fill her up, get some good seats right on the first base line, and don't worry about it. Besides, your tab at the fish market has gone way down...
Sheila posted 02-26-2005 02:31 AM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
Andy, ain't that the truth! We enjoyed a fine lobster dinner here tonight :)

Tony, when we see you at the rendezvous, perhaps you can work your gentle persuasion on my beloved husband. I am the household correspondent. I am also content to just accept the fuel dock situation. He's the one who's all ornery about it :)

BTW, I'm thinking of asking him if we can't make a pale ale to bring up to the delta in May :)

AZdave posted 03-02-2005 01:20 AM ET (US)     Profile for AZdave  Send Email to AZdave     
Sheila, the economics don't mean anything. If it pleases you, or your fuel tank carrier to save money, and not support a business with a premium price and no service - then go for it. You do not have to keep the built in tank full. It's extra weight to move around, and gasoline will happily evaporate to fill any extra space in your fuel tank. You might think about a fuel stabilizer. They are readily available at any auto parts store.
You really need to fill the tanks on the ground when at the gas station. Once filled and sealed they are no more hazardous than the plastic tank that probably holds the fuel for your vehicle.
Remember that the marina is not only charging you more for the fuel, but also not paying road tax on the fuel they sell. Good work if you can get it.
Your boat looks great. We need to drive out there, and dunk our boat in the ocean sometime. Enjoy..
Dave
Sheila posted 03-02-2005 06:41 AM ET (US)     Profile for Sheila  Send Email to Sheila     
Dave, thanks! I know about filling gas containers properly; we do own a lawn mower. :)

Be sure to let us know if you decide to bring your boat out.

JMARTIN posted 03-04-2005 10:01 AM ET (US)     Profile for JMARTIN  Send Email to JMARTIN     
Here in Washington State, the marina does pay the Federal tax of .184 and the State tax of .28 cents per gallon on the gasoline they sell. You can apply for a refund of the State tax, but then you will pay the State sales tax. The Federal tax can be claimed as a deduction on your income tax only if the fuel is used by a commercial vessel used for fishing purposes. With my prediction of marina fuel at 3.50 a gallon this summer in Puget Sound, the sales tax will be around .24 cents per gallon. If fuel costs continue to go up with State and Federal taxes a fixed number and the sales tax a precentage figure, there will be a point where it costs less to pay the "road taxes" instead of the sales tax. John

Post New Topic  Post Reply
Hop to:


Contact Us | RETURN to ContinuousWave Top Page

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Freeware Version 2000
Purchase our Licensed Version- which adds many more features!
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 2000.